Hacker News Reader

The first two examples you provided (Kleenex and Disney) have nothing to do with quality, and everything to do with trademarks. If they do not aggressively defend their trademark, even from tiny, rural daycares with 10 kids, then there is a chance they can lose their trademark and it can become generic (see aspirin, cellophane, escalator, etc).

View on HN

Sure, I agree, but the larger point is the same: some companies choose to go overboard to protect their brand. The ways they do it is different, but the reason is the same.

A point where all the constituent examples are false is probably wrong. The only example thus far is one iPhone that caught fire. We have more than one car that caught fire and no ban on third party repairs for cars.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com