British Women Killed by Men They Previously Reported to Police
broadly.vice.com
broadly.vice.com
Last month a woman activated one, the cops were there in 7 minutes, sadly too late [0].
So even if cops have a good formation, horrible things like that happens.
And we all know it’s hard to change mentalities. It will sadly still be a long road to prevent horror.
[0] https://mobile.francetvinfo.fr/societe/violences-faites-aux-... (in french)
“Trained” is an important part of that - both in preventing someone from harming them and enabling them to be confident in their ability to protect themselves.
I mention this not to start a flamewar on HN but to underscore that this is a very real problem that many people face and to urge people to help be part of mitigating it.
So are the British police underfunded, or just unwilling, to investigate abuse?
Note that uk crime statistics come in two forms: the crime survey (which are statistically sound) and police recorded crime (which are seen as unreliable). We've made some effort to get police to correctly record crime, but there's still a number of things where police will say "this is domestic, and not a police matter", or "this is civil, and not a police matter".
Other than relying on 100% of police to be 100% ethical (and even without congnitive biases), which obviously isn’t ever going to be the case, third parties are probably always going to be necessary to improve accuracy.
Would that be too tall an order for you?
They're asking for better enforcement of non-contact orders (which are granted by judges, in court), especially in cases where the person already has a conviction for violence.
49 is a small number, but these are all preventable deaths and they're all a result of a system that fails to protect victims of domestic violence.
1. https://www.ons.gov.uk/generator?uri=/peoplepopulationandcom...
Outsider Question: Does the UK operate on presumed guilt or presumed innocence?
If the latter, what options do the police have? In the US, although state-by-state, we have options ranging from "The accused automatically is arrested / sent before a judge" to "temporary restraining order, and at least one party must vacate the premises" to "nothing."