If the universe is not truly quantized, then there is nothing to count. By extension, mathematics is not related to physical reality, and it makes no sense to apply mathematical notions of infinity to the universe in such speculative ways.
If the universe is not truly quantized, then there is nothing to count. By extension, mathematics is not related to physical reality, and it makes no sense to apply mathematical notions of infinity to the universe in such speculative ways.
Even for people don't accept the "monism" (to use a metaphor to the monism/ dualism debate of the human mind and body) of physics and mathematics, these same people cannot avoid accepting that correctly applied theoretical manipulations of mathematical symbols jive perfectly well with the predicted, physical outcome they represent. Does claiming that the numbers don't mean anything mean anything?
>"...cannot avoid accepting that correctly applied theoretical manipulations of mathematical symbols jive perfectly well with the predicted, physical outcome they represent."
Close, except for "perfectly". Mathematics and other scientific models are approximations of reality and nothing more. They are fantastic tools but don't be misled into thinking they give a "perfect" picture.
How does that follow? Mathematics is perfectly capable of modeling continuous quantities.
What, to you, would not qualify as a human abstraction?
> How do you define quantity, and can you do it without the notion of counting and discrete objects?
Absolutely. See Tarski's axiomatization of the real numbers, for instance.
Nothing insofar as "what" implies a load of human abstractions. But it's clear that there is a lot of "stuff" out there that no human has ever experienced. It is extremely improbable that humans exist at a "Goldilock's scale" wherein we are even physically capable of experiencing "everything" and of finding boundaries on the universe.
> Absolutely. See Tarski's axiomatization of the real numbers, for instance.
I meant counting in the broadest sense, which is where numbers themselves emerge from. It seems plausible that there are alien modes of cognition that don't rely on the notion of object and can approach continuous "stuff" more directly. Maybe even some terrestrial organisms work this way.
Are you asking how define quantity without quantity?
Also, I think it's fair to say there are quantities that no human has ever "experienced".