Founding Fathers Version 2.0
dilbert.com
dilbert.com
His proposed course of action is to redesign "the system."
This presumes that "the system" as it currently exists reflects the original design. Which it manifestly does not. Not only was the Constitution amended 27 times, vast parts of the federal government are not even close to constitutional in a way that the Founders would have recognized.
And if the system no longer works as designed, that doesn't actually pinpoint what the problem is. What is causing it not to work? If a system no longer produces the desired outputs, is it because the system is broken or because you're feeding it garbage inputs? As George Carlin said about American politics, "garbage in, garbage out" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIraCchPDhk&NR=1
So, Adams is calling for people to design a new system that will accept garbage inputs and produce desirable outputs. Moreover, he ignores that the current system-as-is-operated is not a reflection of the system-as-designed. Asking for a redesign of the original spec and blaming the original spec, when current practice flouts with contempt the original spec, simply misses the point and will produce an embarrassing misdiagnosis from which an embarrassingly incorrect solution will be derived.
I think that our best hope for innovation in government is to open a new frontier, perhaps in the ocean with projects like seasteading (http://seasteading.org/) or in outer space. We need people to found new nations in places that are free from any existing form of government (and don't have existing residents).
I think it is much more likely that we will be able to enact real change in America when there is a better example that is actually functioning in the real world. If we didn't have the example of the United States, would democracy (or democratic republics) be nearly as widespread in the world today? I suspect most of us would still be living under monarchies.
Wouldn't it be easier to create an undersea or polar society before trying to create one in space?
Jefferson: "The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants."
(John) Adams: "Democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts and murders itself. There was never a democracy that did not commit suicide."
So they'd expect us to have "upgraded" by the 200-something year mark?
Just like in the US, which also was quite lucky in the same way.
While previous societies had their golden ages, their invariably sunk back into the mediocrity that they came from. The Dutch and English finally hit a sweet spot, and their societies keep thriving in absolute terms. Not to mention that they exported their way of living to the rest of the world.
It does work, mainly because it was designed by hackers...
Think about it, our government is based upon an application that was launched 15 years before Babbage was even born!
It has redundancy (feds and states), load balancing (redistricting), semi-autonomous components (local governments), built-in testing (checks and balances), and even maintains itself (constitutional amendments).
I didn't say that it always runs well, but it keeps on running. I only wish that I can launch something that runs for 230 years.
Let's be more constructive here. For starters, how many people know their local reps and actually expect said reps to improve the quality of life in their neighborhood? Why is that?
U.S. government is not all that different (in the big picture) from most other governments and the reason is because it's a result of a long evolution of a system whose basic blocks are not that different from those in Roman empire.
Sure, if you go deep enough, there will be plenty of differences between U.S. system, French system or German system, but they all share the attributes you mentioned (local governance, various checks and balances in the system, a way to modify the laws).
I found it quite interesting, and I am only 24, now, and was younger then still.
One notable thing about the Swiss political system is, that in general each level of government spends as much as it earns in taxes. I.e. there are no huge transfers between federal and state (=Canton) level.
Shivers of "Brave New World" ran down my spine as I read this sentence. It's safe, clean, and orderly because it's incredibly conservative and repressive - culturally and politically. I mean come on, can you seriously buy that only a single person stepped forth to run for the highest office of the land? Or that a single party has 97.6% representation in parliament?
IMHO this is too high of a price to pay. This is a fine example of a place that has thrown away the heterogeneity of life, the celebration of differences and quirks, in exchange for strictly enforced harmony. No thanks - some things are worth the dirt and grime, the chaos of disagreement and protest.
You mentioned Hong Kong in another post - I'd much rather explore Hong Kong's system than Singapore's. It's dirtier, grimier, but much more human and IMHO real. It's free market almost to a fault, and is IMHO a pretty damn good example of libertarianism as a success rather than Singapore's story of centralized one-party rule.
Your idea of "well governed" seems to have an awful lot to do with lacking in things that ruffle feathers and make people uncomfortable. IMHO the mark of an enlightened society and people is its ability to integrate individualism and inevitable disagreements into the core of how its society functions - rather than seek to squash all semblance of it in exchange for artificial harmony.
[edit] I also find it somewhat distasteful that we harp on China for its human rights abuses, its repressive single-party rule, and its incredibly socially conservative policies... yet we give Singapore a free pass. I suppose all of the above is okay as long as quality of life is high, economy is good, and everything gleaming and spotlessly clean.
That you do not like Singaporean society is neither here nor there, and actually rather separate from the government. Your (presumably hippy) sensibilities might actually appreciate it's multi-ethnic and fairly harmonious.
Lee Kuan Yew will go down as one the great men of the 20th century.
You mean things like crime, disease, decay, unsafe conditions, corruption, bureaucracy, and waste? Yeah, those ruffle my feathers, and I think eliminating those things and striving for their elimination is an element of good governance.
> This is a fine example of a place that has thrown away the heterogeneity of life, the celebration of differences and quirks, in exchange for strictly enforced harmony.
That's nonsense. There's nightclubs, art, technology, universities, fashion, discussion groups, live music, things to do, meetup groups... they're fairly relaxed about letting you in and out, and there's a fusion of Chinese, Southeast Asian, Western, and Japanese culture.
Your post is just so entirely off the mark - "a place that has thrown away the heterogeneity of life" - that I have to ask before continuing to discuss: Have you actually been to Singapore?
Looking only at their pragmatic decision-making and not at their moral stances, can you substantially back this up?
You could argue that China is now successful despite it's government, not because of it.
(My opinions regarding China are neither strong nor well-informed, I'm just playing devil's advocate.)
China is not well run. The economy remains under the heavy thumb of the state and is not really serving the needs of the people. Consumption as a share of GDP is actually going down. Massive malinvestments from state connected banks and industries are piling up and will explode. The regional party bosses are still basically highly corrupt gangster thugs.
The only way you can look at china and think "Success STory!" is by drawing a GDP or foreign reserves chart. It says nothing about being a person under the chinese government.
Hey, I was doing that. (Though I do actually believe that the recent Chinese success is owed to ordinary Chinese not their government.) Though you can't deny that Deng Xiaoping was infinitely more sane than Mao.