Same thing re data setup. Not the point again. Even if law enforcement hires the world's best computer vision experts (fat chance, it'll go to cheapest contractor) this is a note that there can be mistakes that get people killed.
Same thing re data setup. Not the point again. Even if law enforcement hires the world's best computer vision experts (fat chance, it'll go to cheapest contractor) this is a note that there can be mistakes that get people killed.
Regarding sketches, they're actually interesting because they force a human to exercise judgement, being ambiguous by nature. This is fine - any law enforcement officer stopping someone who looks like a sketch is going to give them the benefit of the doubt. On the other hand, if a computer tells an officer a person ahead is an 89% match with a known killer, the conversation will start with guns drawn, and that will greatly increase the likelyhood of things going south.
You really don't want to be scanned by a trigger happy cop having a bad day. God knows who you happen to look like from that angle.
That is where the two sides of this argument diverge. First: That things "will start with guns drawn". And Second: That things are more likely to "go south" for an innocent individual incorrectly blamed by this.
If police engage a target with a weapon already drawn, there is a long list of things that person can do that will get them shot, and a very short (and often unclear) list of actions that will keep them safe.
Source: 10 years PMO in the Marine Corps, 1 month SFPD (then quit because their training was so shitty)
For the most part, this sort of article makes things seem like there will be some sort of racial-based, dystopian police future where automated algorithms will target people and have them put into jail. I don't see that happening in the near future at all. The police departments' personnel currently using this probably LOOK at the matches and only then make a further call. Just like I would assume AFIS fingerprint hit results are double-checked by skilled operators after matching to reduce false-positives.