Facebook’s “downvote” system begins rolling out wider in US
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
I don't think it will make any comment section better and such mechanisms usually tend to push communities to one extreme or the other. Imagine if twitter had voting...
Actually - now that I am thinking about this, yes, please, give me this option. Even as an opt-in option. I still want to follow news and other organizations. And maybe even comment, but I only want organization itself, and my friends to see my comments. And I only want to see what my friends comment. I am ok with my small echo chamber.
Currently it's soul crushing to look at the comments section on almost any news postings. Vitriol and ignorance run strong there.
I have definitely witnessed HN's downvote system used frequently for other reasons, so if we're comparing against HN, I don't see how they can keep it to those reasons either...
So, no, not getting pushback in comments is not supporting evidence for improper use of downvotes, it is the intent of downvotes.
https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/E5uNNxmn...
And not becausse it was submitted and discussed elsewwhere.
https://hn.algolia.com/?query=facebook%20sandy%20hook&sort=b...
This sounds like a really confusing user experience. Also, showing the vote number in addition to reactions complicates the social signaling.
I know that's kind of snarky, but in all seriousness, I don't trust the average person to know what's civil or irrelevant. Everyone talks about information and conversation bubbles, yet Big Tech continues to cause the problem that everyone and their grandma knows that they create, and we accept it because it's framed as a new toy.
It's as if Facebook isn't as unfun as it gets at this point. The only people who I know that are active on it are old people, and my friends in my age range are decreasingly online and even less active. The more that it exists to satisfy perpetual malcontents, the less useful it seems to be.
IMO showing a score is unproductive for all parties involved — it encourages up/down brigades, and conflates popular opinion with useful discussion.
Perfect example, a few weeks ago someone wrote something along the lines of "Harassing Trump's cabinet is getting results" - now I don't particularly follow the news so I have no idea if anything genuinely came about of the harassment - so I asked "What outcomes have there been?" and I watched that question get downvoted and upvoted oscillating back and forth until several hours later someone replied that Scott Pruit had resigned, stating the harassment as the reason why at which point I thanked the replier for actually taking the time to provide a constructive response.
Too often folks just assume intent for every little comment or question and use a downvote to say "I don't like your opinion" regardless of how valid or invalid it may be. I've been own Hacker News for many years, and it's definitely gotten worse, but this has always been a bit of a bastion of maturity. Not always, but it's better than discussing on Reddit and watching the Dunning-Kruger effect in real-time.
I can only imagine Facebook with downvotes will be another rehash of Reddit comments. The beauty of Facebook not having a fire-and-forget downvote system is that it actually requires one to write out their displeasure so it at least forces some semblance of dialogue.
What I don't like about downvoting is the possibility that my post will disappear. I understand that there's a utility to it, but I almost never write comments with the intent to troll people so it's tragic for me to write something honest only for it to be banished and never taken seriously by the few people out there who might actually do so or benefit from what I have to say. If that never happened, I'd just think downvotes are funny.
I'm sure I've knee-jerk downvoted before, but I usually only downvote if there's something off-topic or uncivil. I don't even downvote most jokes, although I know there's a thing about joking here.
Full
> Full
I understand all of the words but I can't figure out how to read this.
What are you getting at here?
Personally, I don't love that one bit [1], so if I'm asking a genuine question on contentious topic, where my actual intent is to get an answer from someone more knowledgable than me, I make sure to specify that intent, including professing my ignorance and disclaiming any preconceived notions.
One might argue that I shouldn't have to do that, but that's sort of pointless. I'm happy to do whatever it takes to get an honest answer faster, such I might be able to participate more meaningfully in the thread. I've found HN threads to be very ephemeral (and the fact that it's still possible to reply after 2+ days, when there's no notification system, to be a bit bizarre).
[1] Not because I care about karma but because my goal is to engage in conversation that gratifies intellectual curiosity, rather than attracting clicks on the up or down arrows.
Are you implying you trust the average HNer?
I sure as hell don't. People suck. Even the "smart" ones. Everone's an idiot when it comes to things outside of whatever their specialized knowledge is in.
Facebook has over two billion users - including a likely decent number of HN users. Describing a network and userbase of that scale and complexity in such dismissive and simplistic terms is just baseless elitism.
Second, there is no quantifiable measure of validity or quality with which one could make a meaningful comparison.
Third, the sets of Facebook and Hacker News (and Twitter, Reddit, 4chan, etc) users likely overlap significantly, calling the premise of distinct userbases with distinct social and intellectual qualities into question.
However, I was not addressing the question in a data-driven sense, hence why I said "In my experience." My subjective experience tells me that one group of people is more likely, even if that likelihood is ever so small, to make a more reasonable judgment in a particular area than a different group. Now everyone's experience is going to be different, but I never claimed that my experience is universal. In my experience, the very kind of conversation that we are having is much less likely to end well if it was to take place anywhere on Facebook. People on Facebook have threatened me several times for saying far more milquetoast things than I say on HN, yet on HN I've not once received a single threat. Whatever it is about Facebook, I've found that its users on average are much more likely to jump down the throats of others than to have a real conversation. If you can't agree that personal experience can't mean anything to the person having such experience, then we're at an impasse.
I will admit HN downvoting is not as terrible as Reddit or Meta Stack Exchange, but to maintain civility a downvote should require an explanation.
Yes, that's the entire point. But one person's groupthink and mob rule is another person's cultural last bastion against Eternal September.
>but to maintain civility a downvote should require an explanation.
I don't believe civility is something that can be engineered though a UI, it has to arise organically within the community, and be enforced through personal interactions, as it is within any real-life social group.
And if someone could provide a reasoned, well thought out explanation as to why they would downvote a comment, they could just as well reply with that rebuttal, and the downvote wouldn't be necessary.
Downvotes are only useful as a proxy for collective opinion, a means of adding dissent without effort. If someone is going to downvote and not bother with a reply, chances are their explanation wouldn't be worth reading to begin with.
That's my point. To promote civility, respond to a person with a rebuttal (just like you did) and not a drive-by downvote. A downvote shouldn't come to mean "I disagree".
I will say that there needs to be some mechanism that says "This comment does not meet the standards of HN" i.e. when someone posts something inflammatory or offensive. But that mechanism shouldn't deduct rep points until a certain threshold is met.