All you need is another port in addition to the regular SMTP port. They are not mutually exclusive.
Unless you're recommending to not fall back to port 25 after a failed connection to the tls-on-connect port. In which case, see the comment you were replying to where I said it would be backwards incompatible.
Both of the solutions I mentioned are backwards compatible, and protected from a similar downgrade situation.
IMHO, being backwards compatible is necessary for a transition period. The messaging to SMTP operators should be... get on board, or you are going to start losing mail in 1 year.
Even Chrome is going to show all http as insecure in the very near future. Which reminds me... I need to get all my sites upgraded.