Jackson is probably the biggest tourist destination in our tiny little state, so yes, we leave extra room for visitors.
Jackson is probably the biggest tourist destination in our tiny little state, so yes, we leave extra room for visitors.
> Jackson’s plentiful parking supply was underutilized. Despite its small land area and population, millions of visitors drive through the city every year so it is plausible that Jackson needs a lot of parking. But a Jackson-commissioned parking occupancy study of the residential core and midtown areas during peak tourist season in 2017 by Kimberly-Horn found, on average, 68 percent of parking stalls were empty in the residential core, and 61 percent were vacant in the midtown area. Occupancy peaked at 43 percent for the residential core and 51 percent for midtown. These low occupancy rates could suggest that parking is overpriced in Jackson, but at the time of this study, all parking in Jackson was provided at no cost. The conclusion must be that Jackson has an oversupply of parking.
I am unable to find the original study, cited as "Town Of Jackson Parking Garage Challenges to Success" from http://townofjackson.com/ services/police/pr/parking-garage-challenges-success/ .
EDIT: in looking around, I found this Reddit comment - https://www.reddit.com/r/JacksonHole/comments/6bpvhl/town_of... - that the town has such a housing crunch in summer that they will be renting out parking spaces as housing.
That fits in with the thesis that there is too much free parking in Jackson.
Parking is both spatial and temporal. That's why all those empty spaces in Jackson Wyoming don't alleviate parking woes in lower Manhattan. The spatial frequencies at which parking spaces are fungible are less than 400m. Often much less. When human preference comes into play 4m (one stall) can effect selection.
Indeed, the point of many of these "there is too much (often free) parking" pieces is that the optimization efforts have historically only considered the needs of drivers and/or design principles that were more ideological than anything based on reality.
As I pointed out, it seems that Jackson is willing to rent out parking spots for housing, which suggests that they think there is too much free parking at the height of the tourist season, and not enough housing.
I don't see the point of your seemingly ad hominem statements. Eg, "internet personality"? What does that mean? Wouldn't "urban studies theorist" or "best-selling author" be better descriptions?
Since it wasn't Florida making the statement I quoted - it was not made by an 'internet personality' - does it make the statement more accurate?
If only we could find the "Town Of Jackson Parking Garage Challenges to Success" document.
So anyway, being a diligent design professional, I went to the planning department library and studied all the previous downtown parking studies I was able to find on the shelves. About a dozen going back to 1961...roughly forty years worth. Each of them was similar in that if parking was free in 1961, the 1961 study recommended charging for parking. The 1965 study would recommend making parking free. The 1970 study would recommend installing parking meters. The 1974 study would recommend taking parking meters out...and so on. In 2001, paid parking was prevelant. You can guess at the options under consideration.
To Richard Florida's credit, he doesn't have to vary his policy pitch. There's always a market for voices advocating exclusionary policies for urban neighborhoods...e.g The Mortgage Bankers Association that commissioned the study and Parkingmill that is in the business of managing scarce parking. Richard Florida doesn't actually do studies. Influencers don't do studies.