I'm not trying to provoke with the above, I'm just pointing out that the argument doesn't hold water if you look at it in its strictest terms and apply it universally.
This is what turned me off the book and its also what turned me off the writings of Jiddhu Krishnamurti (accused of committing adultery with his best friend's wife).
I'd be glad to continue discussing this with you outside of HN. Feel free to email me at jrhunter at hotmail dot com