I thought I was supposed to not like this guy.
I thought I was supposed to not like this guy.
I'm curious: donations to whom?
The FCC doesn't have campaigns, so any "donations" aren't campaign contributions.
Well, and the natural monopoly of an upfront capital intensive venture that might not pay for itself if you only get 50% of the market...
I feel like the right order of operations if you did believe in deregulation and encouraging competition would be to ensure there was competition between ISPs and then remove the net neutrality laws though, not the other way around.
I still think internet access should be treated similarly to water/power etc though.
Net neutrality, with respect to content, isn’t really an issue, since 99.9% of content is made overseas.
New Zealand doesn't need net neutrality, because it has something better.
In the US, the ISP is one company that owns the lines and sells its services to customers. They also typically bundle cable tv packages. Many customers are serviced by only one or two ISPs. Setting up a competing ISPs requires laying new cable/fiber.
In New Zealand, the ISPs and the companies which own the lines are different companies (as enforced by regulations). ComCom also regulates the price that the line company can charge the ISP.
This makes setting up a competing ISP easy. Buy some capacity on international fiber links, set up some routing equipment in a peering exchange and contract Chorus/Enable to hook up your customers.
Incidentally, this is how power companies work in NZ too. There have been quite a few new retail power competitors launched over the last 10 years.
Arguing for completing removing regulation is indeed quite silly.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/12/ajit-pai-jokes-a...
Keeping it or removing it won't do anything to spur connection competition.
There are three options.
1. Technology inflection forces greater competition, such as Starlink or 5G. 1a would be that an extremely deep pocket competitor forces some improvement; that works at least temporarily, however I'm skeptical that's sustainable (as witnessed by Google's pull-back).
2. The government makes smart decisions regulation wise, that help to smooth a path for increased competition. That includes things like one touch make ready, dig once fiber rules, and blocking munis from signing cable/etc monopoly agreements.
3. Nationalize the infrastructure and allow anyone to rent it. That's too far fetched (unrealistic) for the US as a mostly market system, to go that direction from a heavily privatized market. 3a would be, pass a law stipulating that muni broadband can't be impeded, if a city or town wants to set up its own network it's legally entitled to attempt it. Every bit of added competition around the country helps.
Any combination of those is a big assist. The US is a top 15 broadband country currently, and most of the nations in front of it are tiny (except Japan and South Korea, both of which have hyper population concentration in just a few cities). We've made tremendous progress from how far we were lagging behind just six or seven years ago. Keep throwing more of the above onto that momentum, and it will keep the US competitive in that top echelon, which is a great outcome. Any time a country the size of the US (not just eg a state like Massachusetts) can keep up with countries like Denmark, Finland, Switzerland and Sweden on broadband, or any infrastructure frankly, it's a big deal.
It would be terribly inconvenient for them to have to go through the same process for their 5G deployment.
That's where I'm placing my bet.
Also, I realize your comment was probably some combination of jest or sarcasm.