I don't know if it has long term legs or is just an (extended, at this point) fad, since I've never used one or done soulcycle or whatever, but all the stuff that bugged you about it is the selling point. The hook is that nobody ends up using standalone just-do-what-you-will fitness gear (I do have experience on this side!). Some level of "training" programming has been much more effective for a lot of people, and this is taking this outside the studio into a broadcast form.
My suspicion is that once you take it out of the class setting you've lost that hook, though.