Hacker News Reader

Comment by volkk | Hacker News Reader

I think I see what you did there, but I don't think it's an apt comparison. Watching people compete has been done for as long as civilization has been around, and there is something not only interesting but inspiring watching certain people that are the best at what they do compete against others.

Watching Twitch streams of people sitting there either putting on makeup, or some guy sitting in McDonalds eating a cheeseburger spouting memes is the ultimate form of narcissism. It doesn't develop anything positive but instead indulges the wrong aspects of people. Letting kids, who soak up everything, watch this daily is extremely poisonous and develops the wrong values.

View on HN

Twitch also features people competing in games.

And people have been watching people do banal things forever as well. Plays, soap operas. Wasn't Seinfeld famously referred to as the show about nothing? What about community busy-bodies? What about birdwatchers?

I do agree that there are negatives here, but you're bringing up the worst of Twitch. Of course I don't want my kid obsessions over someone who happens to have a smart phone, a twitch account, and a +2 CHA modifier. But you can't bring up the Olympics as one counterexample, and some idiot eating a burger as another.

Also, what's wrong with watching someone put on make-up? Did you never watch Bob Ross paint a happy little tree?

Well I'm mostly bringing up the worst of twitch because that's what this article is focusing on. In terms of watching e-sports, that's easily comparable to watching basketball on TV. I do the same thing.

What I'm bringing up is the IRL streams. If you're comparing the genius of Seinfeld to the mindnumbing garbage that you see on those streams, then I'm not sure what we're discussing here at all.

I'm also not sure why I can't bring up the Olympics since your initial point is exactly just that except using baseball as an example.

Watching someone put on makeup as an ASMR sort of thing like Bob Ross is also fine. You're missing the point of what I'm trying to say here. Bob Ross didn't wear skimpy clothes and share racist opinions all day on TV, either. He sat there and painted. There wasn't any romantic undertones with his viewers if they watched him long enough or paid him enough money. It's honestly crazy to me that I even have to have this argument and that this isn't objectively agreed upon.

Yeah, you're right. I still don't think it's the end of the world - it doesn't seem significantly different to me than people getting hooked on soap operas, but you're definitely right that this is much more aimed at children and young people than other media, and we don't really have a good way of educating kids about why the shitty shows are shitty.

I exclusively watch e-sports and other competitve gaming on Twitch, for the same reasons someone might tune into the World Cup or the MLB playoffs. You said it better than I could:

>there is something not only interesting but inspiring watching certain people that are the best at what they do compete against others

Does that make me someone to be pitied, in your opinion? Do you question my morality, or the way I was raised?

Nope, not talking about pros playing esports. I'm talking about the IRL streams

Reply on news.ycombinator.com