SF Is Fighting the Scooter Trend with Poop and Vandalism
motherboard.vice.com
motherboard.vice.com
Here are some I imagine:
1. scooters parked in ways that are perceived as inappropriate, obtrusive, invasive, dangerous etc.
2. “get off my sidewalk” sentiment.
3. Scooters as being perceived as “another aspect of the rich people’s colonization of our city/communities” + “F the rich/hipsters” attitude.
4. Systematized anticompetitive activity from ...?
What else? I’m sure I’m just scratching the surface.
Anyone from SF with some insight?
Some people have taken to throwing the bikes or scooters into the rivers when they show up now as a "fuck you" to the companies who are giving a "fuck you" to their town
For example, require standard, short, clearly identifiable serial codes to make it easy to issue tickets when scooters are parked inappropriately. Because the scooter companies track the users, they then have the capability to push the costs onto the irresponsible rider.[1]
Frankly, I just don't get how people manage to use a nuisance to justify vandalism. I mean, I do get it--it's thinly veiled class and anti-corporate anger. But it's cowardly. Once upon a time real civil disobedience came with consequences, and even then activists didn't shamelessly destroy private property. Indeed, the personal consequences are what made the activism both substantive and powerful. Perhaps if these people invited the police to come watch them dump the scooters into the river en masse then I'd respect them even if I disagreed with them.
[1] Yes, you can't prove a passerby didn't move the scooter. But the scooter company would have to pay regardless, and enough of the costs will be passed on to users that behaviors would change.
Of course, I'm not going to conflate "reasonable" with "expedient to the growth needs of <random_startup>".
Having dispensed with any decent respect for the city's prerogative to legislate commercial conduct for the well-being of all residents, the scooter companies chose to annex public sidewalks for storing their assets. As a citizen, that sort of flagrant disrespect for civil mores doesn't make me very sympathetic to whatever problems their littering policy causes the scooter-rental entrepreneurs.
It's not civil disobedience to get rid of these things when they're left on the sidewalk. It is fidelity to an ideal of civil society where sidewalks are for walking, and not to be blithely annexed by people with more venture funding than manners.
My preferred take would be to collect a bunch of em, pull the electronics & batteries, and weld them into a jungle-gym for a park or elementary school that needs one.
Honestly I'm surprised the town's havent done more to these companies. Apparently they confiscate equipment when found but the company is can pick it up with no cost. It degrades the rule of law when one entity can blatantly disregard the laws for their own benefit
Edit: Additionally, what's the economic difference between someone destroying a bit of capital, a scooter for example, and someone performing a sit in and blocking a service oriented business from serving paying customers. Both cost the businesses money, but the current behavior is somehow morally different? If the companies had attempted to stay within the confines of the law I might agree with you, but once they ignored it they lost all ability to claim any sort of high ground. A number of people are tired of these giant vc backed companies coming into their towns and completely ignoring all laws and not even pretending to be civil.
The problem is that the scooter companies didn't bother to work with cities to set up infrastructure for the scooters and are simply relying on public sidewalks for storage. In many cases, this is after the local jurisdiction has asked them to remove their scooters pending the formulation of rules--and in Santa Monica's case despite the promulgation of rules limiting the number of scooters.
They ignore the law when given the least bit of inconvenience , so why would anyone respect their property rights is the thinking that's going on.
I'm really not a fan of companies flouting the law, but Atlanta complaining about bad use of space by vehicles is like Trump complaining about the lack of fact-checkers in journalism. If you're going to make regulations, there should be some semblance of equitable treatment for all involved.
(Technically in CA and most other states you need to turn the property over to the police before it can be considered lost or abandoned by its owner.)