I'm a newcomer to Hacker News, but I have been a user of Stack Overflow and, more generally, Stack Exchange for some time. So perhaps I can still speak about the experience of a newcomer.
In my experience, neither site suffers fools gladly.
This morning I made a comment on a post on the first page of Hacker News. In it, I made reference to a project that I am working on independently.
A more senior user of Hacker News read my comment, considered it self-serving, and primarily a reference to my product. Then, he downvoted my comment (something I cannot do as a newcomer), looked at my other comments (something I didn't know how to do until later), and left a comment saying that nearly all of my comments on this site referenced my project and weren't substantively about the articles where they appeared.
As soon as I saw this comment I apologized, and said I wished that I could delete my comment about which that user was complaining.
Later in the day I learned how to see all of my comments by studying my profile. The comment I was criticized for was my second comment on Hacker News.
Whether the other user's criticism was appropriate or not, I got downvoted by at least a few other people after I apologized.
My sense of this situation, therefore, is that the progressive rights systems that give additional rights to users with previous contributions disadvantage new users.
The awarding of points to certain comments by other users and its connection to enhanced rights on Hacker News and other websites such as the Stack Exchange websites encourages certain behaviors that may not be entirely good for the culture of the sites themselves.