https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/06/180622012101.h...
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/06/180622012101.h...
Anyway, recently I wanted to look into whether or not eggs are good for you because those same Keto supporters make noise about how eggs no longer affect (bad?) cholesterol levels and therefore won't contribute to heart disease. You'd think it would be clear. Nope. It's about 50-50 split judging by various links (from seemingly reputable doctors and nutritionists). Even those docs that pay lip service to the changing attitudes towards eggs, don't know what a safe amount is and caution about eating more than X per day or week ... though not because of any specific studies, but just as a precaution. A simple question like "Can I eat 3 eggs for breakfast everyday" has no consensus answer. What the fuck.
Should we heavily invest in Quantified Self as a society? I'm sure we have the technology to make it worthwhile, but I'm not sure most people would be willing to do so due to privacy concerns.
Studies are not just financed by obvious interests in the result, but also they use really poor population samples with horrible falsability and repeatability issues.
The fact that we still don't have a fully functional human body model to test theories on, doesn't help either.
What does this mean?
My best guess is that there must be some kind of fear, among that field's practitioners, that some stupid politicians (gah, redundancy!) would take one look at the project and throw a hissy fit or worse.
You seem to think that effort should translate into understanding. Nature doesn't work this way.
In my opinion, most effort in biomed has been wasted due to poorly designed studies, which is due to NHST (null hypothesis significance testing; ie, testing a null hypothesis rather than the research hypothesis), and all the BS that procedure entails.
So the real reason no one is trying to develop "a fully functional human body model" is that such a model is not even visible on the horizon for a single cell, or even sub-cellular organelle.
Or they do exist, already. All humans are a fully functional human body model.
Not quite, but you are catching on. The rest is mostly a matter of cloning, and providing a standardized nurturing to each clone to eliminate confounding differences. (Perhaps in the far future we will be able to raise one clone, scan its brain, and overwrite the brains of each of the rest of its identical siblings with the scan results.)
For some kinds of research, it even suffices to use a creature who has a hole where humans have a brain.
... ya know, biology sounds really exciting to laymen who don't know any better.
This seems unlikely given that mainstream nutrition science is the same in most of the western world, but the obesity levels are far more severe in the US. From what I hear from friends who have travelled to the US (from the UK), standard portion sizes can be over twice as over on your side of the pond. And it can be very difficult to travel anywhere without a car. Seems to me this might have the bigger effect.
That said nutrition science really is a mess. Hopefully we'll work it out one day :)
I was educated enough to figure things out in adulthood, but you raise a poorly educated populace on that mentality while making the least healthy food cheap and delicious, and shocker we have an obesity epidemic. :P
The cost of a larger portion is minimal relative to the higher price (especially in dishes that are made in large batches anyways). So the restaurant is happy to be getting enough to cover all their costs (and hopefully a little extra), and the customer leaves happy despite paying more.
The downsides in the long-term are that (1) as time goes on and currency inflates, portion sizes get larger and (2) people get used to larger portion sizes and the same meal has less value to the customer over time.
I don't have any data to back this up, but I do believe this sort of feedback loop plays a role in obesity.
This was prompted by an annual checkup with my doctor. I was 265lbs (6'0" tall) at 23 and had a number of issues related to my weight, including high cholesterol and an inflamed liver. My last annual checkup, I was down I think 30-35lbs and everything they tested was back in the normal range. So yeah, portion sizes are important.
2. Sugar. So much sugar. Specifically, corn syrup. The agricultural lobby has successfully obtained so much in the way of subsidies that corn syrup is actually cheaper than cane sugar. It's in everything. Even bread has sugar of some sort added. You know there's a problem when bread brands place advertisements on the packaging that it "contains no corn syrup or high fructose corn syrup".
Combine that with the fact that these effects take years or decades to show themselves, it makes for an area of science with very few hard answers.
I am kind of under the impression that this is generally accepted, at least partially, by pretty much everyone these days, not just Keto people.
As in, the move to remove fats entirely and replace them with carbs is considered today to have been a bad idea, even if no one quite agrees just how bad or just what a better idea is.
Is that not more-or-less consensus today?
The move to reduce fats may or may not have been backed by “mainstream nutrition science”, but replacing them with carbs never was.
But eating carbs was certainly emphasized, eg search Google for food pyramids from the 1970s, their "eat most"categories are usually vegetables and carbs.
There's a difference between “the science was wrong” and “government recommendations served an interest group without being well grounded in science.”
I think that the recommendations either were based on science, or at least weren't really disputed until about 10-15 years ago. Then again, what I think I know about this mostly comes from hearing people talk about the issue, e.g. in interviews, forums, etc. But I haven't really read any of the source material on this (either modern-day or older) so I really have no idea if it's at all true.
Mainstream nutrition fads clearly were. A big part of of those fads were about lay generalization of what science supported for very specific diseases as general advice. Another big part was commercial propaganda from food vendors.
One of the ways people have tried to get around this expense is to take a large population and ask them what they have been eating over their lives. This has two major problems that make it almost useless: People don't remember what they actually ate, only what they think they ate. And there are too many co-founding variables. Some people try to be healthy, so they make lots of changes to their lifestyle, and you can't separate out the effects from diet, exercise, stress levels, and everything else people do.
My understanding from reading the article is the lower threshold is higher than we think. There are still negative effects at what we consider high levels of salt intake.
They also mention same team who did this study published a previous study that met a lot a criticism and they apparently failed to address the criticisms.
So you should probably moderate your salt intake still.
For instance:
> Our findings indicate that inaccurate measurement of sodium intake could be an important contributor to the paradoxical J-shaped findings reported in some cohort studies. Epidemiological studies should not associate health outcomes with unreliable estimates of sodium intake
Basically, this seems to me to argue that the error range in the methods used would be bigger than the relevant range of results discussed, so to draw any conclusion measurements need to be redone.
That would be a bit different from a denial of a specific thesis, although I am sure the researcher must have an opinion on the matter.