There are clearly workloads where the 32 core TR chip does not perform well (probably due to the memory configuration) but it seems pretty good at rendering.
This means AMD manages to execute more work per watt (more energy efficient), and each AMD core uses less power than Intel.
¹ Anantech wrongly lists the TDP as 140W. It's in fact 165W: https://ark.intel.com/products/126699/Intel-Core-i9-7980XE-E...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI9sMfWmCsk&feature=youtu.be...
Its power consumption was 19% higher than the i9-7980XE.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI9sMfWmCsk&feature=youtu.be...
Tom's Hardware saw a stock 2990WX at a lower power consumption than a stock i9-7980XE during a Prime95 "torture loop". Overclocked, the AMD part was higher than the Intel one, but only slightly.
https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-threadripper-...
Where have you seen that it has double the power consumption? Under what workloads?
Personally, I don't care about "weaker cores". If a system has 2048 cores clocked at 7 THz and it is 20% faster at my workload than a single-core CPU at 700 MHz, it is faster.
The fact that the "weaker cored" system is cheaper than the "burly muscly" single core system is a bonus.
Power consumption doesn't even matter that much either. It is the equivalent to a single 60W light bulb (or several of those new-fangled LED bulbs). Big whoop.
But more importantly, The Tech Report looked at task energy for the Threadripper in rendering tasks and found that it took less energy to finish a render than competitorys. It's power was higher but the time was shorter to an even greater extent.
https://techreport.com/review/33977/amd-ryzen-threadripper-2...
So if you're so serious about rendering that you're willing to spend thousands on a good rig for it there really isn't any reason not to use this boy.
[1] https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/Intel-Core-i9-7960X-vs-...
Intel on the other hand needs to manufacture a monolithic CPU that not only is fault free in enough cores, but performs well. That's harder and yields are way lower.
80% yield on a 4 core block is a 16.7% yield on a 32 core block - and that's before binning
AMD has only been doing this "infinity fabric" thing for a year. Intel was caught with their pants down. It seems like Intel is researching chiplet technology and trying to recreate AMD's success here.
It takes several years to create chips. So Intel realistically won't be able to copy the strategy until 2020 or later. But you better bet that Intel is going to be investing heavily into chiplet technology, now that AMD demonstrated how successful it can be.
AMD "upgraded" HyperTransport to Infinity Fabric. Which IIRC uses a bit less power (taking advantage of the shorter, more efficient die-to-die interposer).
Intel has UPI (upgrade over Intel QuickPath), but it hasn't been "shrunk" to chiplet level yet. Intel has EMIB as a physical technology to connect chiplets together... but Intel still needs to create dies and a lower-power protocol for interposer (or maybe EMIB-based) communications.
So Intel has a lot of the technology ready to create a chiplet (like AMD's Zeppelin dies). But Intel wasn't gunning for chiplets as hard as AMD was. Still, Intel demonstrated their chiplet prowess with the Xeon+FPGA over EMIB. So Intel definitely "can" do the chiplet thing, they just are a little bit behind AMD for now.
Also because they didn't have to innovate - no competition since early Opterons.