I wasn't trying to create any definite story, I'm just saying that it is easy to make a historical analogy depending on what you wantto take away from it. China is not the Soviet Union any more than it is the United States. Doing away with the belt and road initiative by painting it as a Soviet vanity project seems too simple, the country is communist only in name.
For me, this narrative seems to be very typical of our European/American mindset. All great infrastructure plans are grandiose planning, we're done growing, we're 2 years away from the next crisis and so forth and projecting it onto China, which seems to have shaken off that very prediction over and over. China's current mode of development does not comply with our 'End of History' like narrative about how countries ought to develop, so we're stuck in a constant loop of shallow pessimistic analogies.
I would want to see an in-depth analysis of the project really looking at the consequences with an eye on the long-term effects rather than just stories about some harbor in Africa falling short of expectations. This is not illuminating.