tl/dr: Different people like different things, and sometimes that changes over time. Huge surprise, or?
I imagine attraction is a non-trivial function of multiple variables for most people. As such it doesn't seem that surprising that for some certain variables have more (or less) influence than for most others.
On a somewhat related note, I truly cannot imagine why anyone would put jelly on a peanut butter sandwich. The thought seems utterly gross to me. But as long as I'm not forced to eat it, I no problem with others having a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Why should I?