>Denying that vitamin D is important seems silly when people who are indoors so often feel remarkably better after spending even just a few hours outside in the sun.
The two things are not exactly the same, however.
If you feel better after a mid-winter break in a sunny place, maybe it is because the mid-winter break in a sunny place or a few hours outside do good, and you should do that.
Staying in a non-sunny environment indoors and taking vitamin D might (or might not) provide the same wellness.
I guess it is the same thing with meal substitutes, maybe (though I doubt it) we have arrived to a point where we could take a single pill or gulp a dose of some (possibly terribly tasting) high-tech mush containing all that is needed, but maybe sitting at a table, making a pause for half an hour, eating some good tasting food, sniffing its aroma, etc. are the things that actually do the good.