Take a look at Bilthoven [0], one of the the most extreme examples I know of. The (roughly) north side is obviously richer, but the contrast is an awful lot smaller than the examples from the BBC.
Now let's look at a somewhat average city, Utrecht. [1] Can you tell me which parts the ultra-rich live? How about now? [2] Amsterdam is pretty much the same story, just like Rotterdam, Den Haag, etc. Sure, there are of course rich and poor people, but there are no slums, let alone slums right next to mansions!
About the message: poor people are living in small, filthy, dilapidated houses right next to the immaculate mansions of the rich. Perhaps the rich could contribute a little towards the living conditions of the poor who helped them to gain their wealth?
[0]: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.1278844,5.1932405,3071m/data=... [1]: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.0981346,5.1310086,3074m/data=... [2]: https://www.google.nl/maps/@52.0999022,5.1106661,2583m/data=...
There are good reasons to be critical of many forms of wealth redistribution, however it does clearly work in some instances. Just ask all the most developed nations, including the US (which has both one of the most progressive taxation systems and one of the largest welfare systems as a share of GDP).
The primary debate is whether there are better approaches, or what degree / what manner of wealth redistribution is ideal, not whether any wealth redistribution can be effective.
"I dont see the problem. If there is a problem I dont know we should solve it. If there is a problem we shouldnt solve it because its natural. If it is a problem and we should deal with it we shouldnt use redistribution."
Isnt there a name for this type of reasoning?
That didn’t happen.
And if it did, it wasn’t that bad.
And if it was, that’s not a big deal.
And if it is, that’s not my fault.
And if it was, I didn’t mean it.
And if I did…
You deserved it.
counterfactual reasoning? if it weren't for the fact that you disagree, you might just call it being thorough.
Originating in the legal profession, argument in the alternative is a strategy in which a lawyer advances several competing (and possibly mutually exclusive) arguments in order to pre-empt objections by his adversary, with the goal of showing that regardless of interpretation there is no reasonable conclusion other than the advocate's.
http://acronymrequired.com/2011/10/the-four-dog-defense.html
You really don't see the issue here? The migration of poor peasants to the cities living in slums is a well known phenomenon even in the UK a lot of slums existed until well after ww2
Of course South Africa has its own tragic post ww2 history I would have thought that most people would have some understanding
Why not? We essentially distributed it up, why can't it come back down?
The very definition of inequality, unfortunately.
Two people each having $5 is a low—inequality situation. One person having $10 and another having $100 is a high inequality situation, even though minimum and average wealth are both higher.
You don't have the regular famines in Bangladesh which I recall from when I was a child.
Those statistics would say the person in the hut is poorer of course, but I would disagree.