Wireguard is awesome, but the kernel module is so far a mess. If you're paranoid I wouldn't rely on it until the code has been cleaned up and perhaps audited.
by @mistaken, not Linus: http://lists.openwall.net/netdev/2018/08/02/124
OpenVPN is a mess. IPSEC and basically all implementations thereof are messes.
(As a personal anecdote, have you ever tried to get OpenVPN to do anything remotely sensible with MTUs or MTU-related ICMP errors? You can’t, because every possible configuration gets it at least partially wrong [0]. Wireguard get it entirely correct AFAICT.)