Let's Stop Pretending Facebook and Twitter's CEOs Can't Fix This Mess
wired.com
wired.com
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI%E2%80%93Apple_encryption_d...
The debate should include discussion of the degree to which these large companies mediate the exercise of fundamental human rights.
I think there's an important distinction in the criticism though, even though the rhetoric might be similar.
Apple was holding its ground against the US Gov't and defense community to avoid setting a dangerous precedent that would violate their user's rights.
While it's true that in some ways Facebook, Youtube, or Twitter are defending user's free speech, I think there's some question as to how they (or their algorithms) promote extreme views.
Does everyone have free speech if you give the most extreme voices a megaphone?
It may be intractable to go 100->0 on harassment. Sure. But what if you could go to 50? To 20?
Is the difficulty in stamping out all harassment enough of a hurdle to not try stamping any of it out? Or is it just window dressing to ignore the issue. She says it's the latter.
If anything, her story makes it clear that it really isn't that hard to identify groups and communities that breed harassment then take action against them.
> difficult and intractable a problem online harassment is
She is saying is that it's only "difficult and intractable" if you operate a social network the way they all do: "engagement" above any other consideration.I don't see a whole lot of calls for genocide on any Apple property. I don't see a whole lot of calls for genocide on HN. Use Twitter in Germany and suddenly the bulk of the NeoNazi tweets disappear.
She's right. Whether you like censorship or hate censorship, it just isn't hard to implement it an order or two of magnitude more effectively than what we have now.
So the next time some journalist writes an article about one of these social networks, it would be great if they got it right. They prattle on and on about how lost Google and Facebook are when it comes to text-filtering and data-mining. It's silly.
Investors wanted growth, and they got growth. Growth also comes with consequences, but it's a lot harder to convince investors you aren't doing work contributing to growth in order to look at non-immediate consequences.
Sites like Facebook, Twitter, etc. need to invent an entirely new language for people to communicate in and simply make the expression of these kinds of ideas semantically impossible.
I don' think they set out trying to do it, but their algorithms do seem to prefer things that get a reaction out of people (positive or negative). If someone posts something hateful, a lot of people may click on it or respond, but that doesn't mean it's good.
Social media companies put a lot of faith being put into machine learning on human behavior, but people don't behave perfectly rationally. Especially when they're scrolling through Twitter to kill time on the can.
People who call for censorship have gone too far, but if you think Facebook/Twitter/whatever are doing an A+ GreatJob when it comes to social responsibility I strongly disagree.
Free speech is very important, especially the one you disagree with.
But it doesn't mean you get to harass people, send death threats, post people's private information (doxxing), and spread nude photos that were never supposed to be released.
That is accurate and there are legal remedies for that. For instance, Kurt Eichenwald, a person on the receiving end of most of the activities you mentioned, collected the evidence and used the justice system to secure a Grand Jury indictment against his harasser [1], [2]
Here is the abridged transcript of the indictment:
> CRIMINAL COMPLAINT I,
> On or about December 15, 2016, in the Dallas Division of the Northern District of Texas and elsewhere, defendant John Rayne Rivello, with the intent to kill, injure, harass, and intimidate, did knowingly and intentionally use an interactive computer service and an electronic communication service to engage in a course of conduct that placed a person in reasonable fear of the death of and serious bodily injury to that person and caused, attempted to cause, and would be reasonably expected to cause substantial emotional distress to that person;
> in that Rivello posed as Twitter user Ari Goldstein and used his Twitter account @jew _goldstein to post an animated Graphics Interchange Format (GIF) on the victim's Twitter feed, knowing that the victim was an epileptic and knowing that the animated GIF was a strobe bearing the message "YOU DESERVE A SEIZURE FOR YOUR POSTS."
And here is the central point
> In violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2261A(2)(A) and (B), and 18 U .S.C. § 226l(b)(3). This criminal complaint is based on the facts set out in the attached affidavit.
Most of the activities you describe, online or whatnot, are already in the US Code as actual crimes. I do not believe private companies should take over the role of the government in policing speech through prior restraint simply out of the possibility of potential criminal activities. It creates a chilling effect on legitimate speech and a dangerous precedent of private companies (potentially in collusion with the government) being in position to stifle speech.
[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/kurt-eichenwald-case-te...
[2] https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/949676/downlo... (pdf)
> Taking down shitty content works...a place for meaningful conversation
Right now you'll find (or won't, rather) people on Twitter banned for sharing factual but 'problematic' news articles or for referencing crime statistics.
A good number of users might find such views 'shitty' and not 'meaningful' and that's where the problem lies - people are being deplatformed, not for the red herrings of doxxing and celeb nudes, but simply for having opposing and uncomfortable opinions.
Again, from the article:
> I still need to use Twitter for work, but my personal view is that any content I contribute is promoting white supremacy
Madness. Anyone with such a bizarre personal view ought not to be taken seriously.
These crime statistics are often being used to push a racist agenda, and private entities are under no obligation to be a platform for that.
> > I still need to use Twitter for work, but my personal view is that any content I contribute is promoting white supremacy
> Madness. Anyone with such a bizarre personal view ought not to be taken seriously.
I will agree that that bit she said is bizarre. Not really sure what she meant by that. I wouldn't dismiss everything else she said just because of one line, though. Each individual statement should be evaluated by its own merits. Picking one statement, using it to decide she's crazy, and then using the opinion that she's crazy to dismiss everything else starts to get close to being an ad hominem.
I agree in part. I don't think the agenda matters though. You shouldn't be banned for sharing facts.
> private entities are under no obligation to be a platform for that.
Of course, but is 'agenda pushing' on a public forum really a surprise? And why can some types of agendas be pushed and not others?
Whether you agree with what's being shared is irrelevant - the point is there should be fairness and consistency when implementing policy. That has not always been the case.
> Picking one statement, using it to decide she's crazy, and then using the opinion that she's crazy to dismiss everything else starts to get close to being an ad hominem.
Sure but if somebody believes that merely posting on Twitter promotes white supremacy, it signals that they're slightly hyperbolic and so should be taken with a pinch of salt.
The agenda absolutely matters (see below). Claiming some of these people are simply "sharing facts" is dishonest. If someone with a racist agenda tweets something about black crime, it's not just for simple educational purposes, they're trying to rationalize attacks on black people. They're trying to stir up their followers to strengthen their hate.
> And why can some types of agendas be pushed and not others?
Because agendas based on racism, homophobia, transphobia, misogyny, etc. are inherently malicious and lead to violence against innocent people who's only "crime" was being black/gay/trans/a woman/etc.
> Whether you agree with what's being shared is irrelevant - the point is there should be fairness and consistency when implementing policy. That has not always been the case.
Agreed, it hasn't always been consistent, and I think that's what Ellen's point. Facebook/Twitter pretend to be against hate speech by banning lesser-known users, but they allowed the popular extremists like Alex Jones and Richard Spencer because they bring in a lot of traffic to the platform. They sold their morals for cash.