CD sales have fallen since 2000. Spotify, in your example, came out 8 years later.
https://www.statista.com/chart/12950/cd-sales-in-the-us/
Conversely, Napster was released in 1999.
https://www.statista.com/chart/12950/cd-sales-in-the-us/
Conversely, Napster was released in 1999.
I recall a report that showed that p2p networks acted primarily like a broadcast medium, which tuned to the most popular works.
The entire free content model has arisen because of tacit acknowledgement of that fact.
Youtube, hell everyone, applies those lessons today.