Well, the question is whether I'm responsible for the use of my computer network. If someone hacks into it and starts using it without me noticing, am I responsible?
Well, the question is whether I'm responsible for the use of my computer network. If someone hacks into it and starts using it without me noticing, am I responsible?
The court is saying "Look, you can't just saying the IP address is the person, you need to offer a reasonable claim that it is". It is not saying IP addresses are useless or that your identity must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Neither my first post nor this post were meant to be normative -- I'm not from the US, the country I am from makes passive filesharing (i.e. uploading while torrenting) more or less legal, and I would be very happy if legal rulings stopped piracy fishing expeditions. I just wanted to describe the substance of the ruling in a more substantial way than the headline did.
The best way I can interpret this is that your post was being deliberately misleading, because you implied that roommates won't invalidate IP authentication, but you actually meant that lying about having roommates won't invalidate IP identification.
Am I missing a more reasonable interpretation?
I think so. I think in more than one way.
GP, if I read correctly, tries to limit the expectations we can have based on this ruling since the circumstances where unusual. (Read GPs post again for more details.)
English is not my first language but GP seemed very clear and easy to read.
Have a look here[1] of the potential actions that can be taken against you and your potential response to those.
In the end it will be a matter of how far you and the other party are willing to push this.
This will be different of course if it can be demonstrated that you intentionally ran the open-wifi to bamboozle or encourage illegal use. (because you advertized for or boasted about it in an online forum for instance).
It is not that simple if you left your car unlocked. Leaving an unlocked car around with the key in the ignition is clearly a public danger.
Having a case where you are guilty whatever you say makes no sense, especially for something where the damages to society are very abstract and not proven, like piracy.
The law suggested may be bad, but it doesn't remove the role of the justice system in determine the existence and degree of liability.
I had a quick google and I found mentions that you will get fines for this. I did not find an example of something bad happening with an unlocked car.
Depends on the act. In the state of Georgia, at least, if a passenger in the car you're driving throws litter out the window, you're responsible (not that this particular law is ever enforced).
So basically all of them? Because I can tell my torrent client to use whatever port I want
IANAL that’s just my personal understanding / belief.
The key point would be the use would have to be unsanctioned and you were totally unaware. Once you give someone your WiFi password, it’s less clear if you have any liability. I’m not sure of any case where the actual user was known but the person who provided the network connection was blamed.
Network access is fairly universal. The particular method used to access the Internet is practically irrelevant. The actor and the act are what is important, not how the packets are routed.
Many states don’t actually have laws about securing firearms directly but have a concept of strict liability about what happens if they are stolen, or stolen and not reported.
Where does this happen?
An example, this is from Verizon[1]
2. Use of your Service and Account and Compliance with Applicable Authority. You are responsible for all use of your Service and account, whether by you or someone using your account with or without your permission, including all secondary or sub-accounts associated with your primary account, and to pay for all activity associated with your account. You agree to comply with all applicable laws, regulations and rules regarding your use of the Service and to only use the Service within the United States (unless otherwise permitted by this Agreement).
3. Restrictions on Use. The Service is a consumer grade service and is not designed for or intended to be used for any commercial purpose. Except as otherwise set forth in this Agreement, you may not resell, re-provision or rent the Service, (either for a fee or without charge) or allow third parties to use the Service via wired, wireless or other means. For example, you may not provide Internet access to third parties through a wired or wireless connection or use the Service to facilitate public Internet access (such as through a Wi-Fi hotspot), use it for high volume purposes, or engage in similar activities that constitute such use (commercial or non-commercial). If you subscribe to a Broadband Service, you may connect multiple computers/devices within a single home to your modem and/or router to access the Service through a single Verizon-issued IP address, and if available through the Service, you may permit guests to access the Internet through your Service’s Wi-Fi capabilities. You also may not exceed the bandwidth usage limitations that Verizon may establish from time to time for the Service, or use the Service to host any type of server. Violation of this Section may result in bandwidth restrictions on your Service or suspension or termination of your Service.
[1]https://www.verizon.com/about/terms-conditions/verizon-onlin...