My first thought was that since the welfare benefits to the employee are tax free this becomes a (marginally) more effective way to “pay” your low-wage employees.
But the marginal tax rate at that part of the curve, taking into account the EITC is close enough to zero that it’s not an issue.
I like the plan, I think that it needs a slight tweak. The fine should be 200% of the subsidy, and perhaps it should only apply to workers working at least 20 hours a week.