Is the Valley Falling out of Love with Options?
techcrunch.com
techcrunch.com
So to the great disappointment of recruiters I started negotiating compensation at my next jobs by always asking to trade some of the options in the package for more cold hard salary cash. I wouldn't say no to options but unless you join a startup very early, they usually are a very risky bet to make up for, say, a pay cut from your previous position. It's served me well. I am not Cresus and I don't drive an expensive sports car but I do have enough in the bank for a few rainy days and I feel safe to be able to take the risks I now take as an entrepreneur myself.
So never forget, short of being lucky, only business owners, stockholders (not option holders) are really poised to make the big bucks if a company makes it to the top. As an employee your options were always planned by the company CFO and its lawyers to be sufficient in numbers to just bring you the equivalent of a nice fat bonus if the company fares well. Not more. If you are an employee, freelancer, or contractor, try to get paid for what you do. Don't say no to options but make sure you don't rely on them to heavily.
So, yes, at the early stages, the Valley remains enamored with "options" and perhaps more so than ever in the 25+ years I have been doing startups. Beyond the early stage, the lack of an IPO market has taken the luster away from the equity grants that used to excite so many in Silicon Valley and the article makes a good point that a noticeable change has occurred at that level.
And yes, I'm now starting to see (potentially) RSUs in bonus packages. (First time I've seen RSUs in 14 years)
I would be nice to have a online tool that did all of these calculations for you - e.g. given estimates of market size, distribution of the sizes of exits etc.
In most cases there's plenty of money to go around when a company is successful. At least enough that the first dozen employees should make far more than they could have at a regular job.
Assume that half the pool is given to the first ten employees - so that's about $1 million each.
I know people in the software field who have "regular jobs" and earn ~$200K and have been for many years.
So I would perhaps disagree with the assertion that being an employee in a successful startup means that you will make "far more" than is possible in a "regular job".
Now this isn't to say that the startup would be a much more interesting experience - but in purely financial terms the rewards of a high earning "regular job" are comparable (and that is ignoring the risk profile of startups).
Wow. Where, and in what branch of the industry?
Twitch.
It's not weird, extra money for employees is an expected consequence of continued competitive overfunding for early stage companies.
This sounds remarkably like what happened to my dad in the late 80s/early 90s. VCs, founders make money, employees get fired and the company gets moved to (wherever-corporate-office). This is not a new trend; to make money in an acquisition, you must be one of the people with a large stake in the company. If you are Joe Programmer, that is probably not you... so ask for a salary.
It may be true that the lottery/pigeon dance effect is kind of wearing off, as there hasn't been a huge IPO (like Google's) in a while. This would make normal employees less likely to bank on a huge IPO.
Could tie a bonus to a metric or give out a percent of revenues... but there is a much bigger tax burden there.
How bad is it going to have to get before investors discover the other 48 states in the U.S.?
And in reply, I'd ask "How long will it be before any of the other 49 states make non-competes unenforceable and forbid companies from laying claim to what you do with your own ideas on your own time and with your own resources?"
I've been trying to figure out why for some time (strong anti-recommendation: Regional Advantage, which gets way too many things dead wrong about the Boston scene (all too often in an "I was there" way...) and feels like a book that cites evidence to prove its thesis without paying any attention to counter-arguments, interpretations or facts).
I can't help but notice that what I've cited is the only unique thing about SV (well, there's earthquakes, but I don't think any non-researcher move there for them), how it had to help the true silicon genesis part of its history (Shockley -> Fairchild -> many companies) and how I've seen the chilling effect that non-competes have on potential startups in the Boston and D.C. areas.