As far as I can tell, the influence of the sponsor is limited to a thank you at lunch and a shout out on the website. But I understand your concern about the tension. This is something that every volunteer organization or meetup group struggles with:
1. It usually costs money to put on an event worth going to. Not a ton, but food, beverages and space aren't free.
2. People prefer free (and tech people tend to expect free).
I know another meetup that struggled for years trying to solve this problem, and never found a satisfactory answer.
The answers I have seen work for groups are:
1. Find sponsors and thank them
2. Charge a membership fee
3. Only do free stuff (meet in the library, or a park)
4. Have the meetup organizer pay out of pocket (a different kind of sponsorship)
5. Be lucky enough to have already acquired some kind of income generation (typically an older established gepup like a fraternal order)
It's a tough problem.
However, the best bang for the buck, in terms of strategic insight, is probably the email list.
That's a big part of what I'm trying to help scale for the group.
You'd have to ask Miles (who commented above) why he made the switch to sponsorship.
We've lucked out in Boulder & Denver where we can make a reservation for that big, but a lot of places I've talked to want event fees, so I'm still going to avoid that, but it'd be nice to have the option.
That’s pretty much the basic concept behind every professional networking conference, doesn’t seem very controversial.
I often have lunch or drinks with other people in our domain, and I don't see why we would ever want a sponsor, we just go out together to eat and/or drink, talk about stuff, you know, just like that.
Could CTO Lunches remain small?
Are you organized as a 501(c)(3), a charity where donations are tax-deductible and therefore must not be used for commercial purposes? (That would be effective but is almost certainly too much overhead.)
(Cool project, btw.)
Since you asked, and I started this project simply to benefit the community, I'll dump my thoughts on scaling here (would appreciate any feedback!)
1. Each city has a captain, who is responsible for setting the time & place of each monthly lunch (and possibly for facilitating monthly local email threads / activity updates). A good captain is key to keeping that small, local community feeling going. <<< This is the main answer to your question.
EDIT: I think it's super important to reiterate that each local captain is an engineering leader themselves. It's not some marketing person from a dev-oriented company.
2. Sponsors -- we only have 1 sponsor right now (name.com), and it's about a month old. I met them while organizing Boulder Startup Week because they were volunteering to help organize BSW too. They're headquatered in Denver, so 1 person from the company comes to the Boulder & Denver lunches (they don't give pitches, they just eat lunch and mingle). I still need to talk with name.com if they're interested in continuing to sponsor the group world wide, which would be cool because they're great at video content and they hate timeshare pitches as much as we do. But if they'd like to keep it local, then I think all sponsors should be local. I know in each startup community there are small to mid size companies doing cool, valuable work and not being jerks about it. Those are the types of sponsors that would be valuable to the group, so that's what I'd help focus on.
3. Even more value -- I really haven't thought this through, but I'd love it if I could spend all of my time providing more value to the group. Outside of the time I've spent being a CTO & co-founder of a VC backed company, I love writing books, doing interviews (Kevin & I did StartupCTO.io, a podcast for a while), putting on events, and building little SaaS tools to help people. I'm not sure how to support myself financially to do that (maybe there's a paid premium membership that's optional for people? But the email list & in person event would always be free! Maybe sponsors help me with that?), but that would be amazing.
Oh and structure of the email list: * Everyone * Colorado * Texas * ...
where members can always email just their local group, but they have the option of participating in or starting discussions with the international community.