Cheaper Battery Is Unveiled as a Step to a Carbon-Free Grid
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zinc%E2%80%93air_battery#Secon...
Or more specifically, what are the answers to these questions:
1. What is the charge/discharge efficiency? This seems to be something lots of the "next generation batteries" in articles are bad at (compared to current commercial batteries)
2. What is the cycle lifetime?
3. What is the power density?
For 2 and 3 there was an article on HN last week I think that was using a gravity potential "battery" that was carbon neutral (and based on super simple physics) simply by using an electric motor to lift weight, and then discharge by doing the reverse.
[edit: Using the power of wikipedia it seems like power density is high, but it also says they're not rechargeable. But also that they are. So can someone who actually knows the chemistry of batteries give a summary?]
That the company has been selling such batteries for a number of years and now is announcing it is going to go big time would seem to indicate it has figured out how to solve these problems, but how does it do it? I looked at the company's web site and it doesn't give any specifics. Though I did read somewhere that it has been granted over a hundred patents, so maybe they give some idea of what they are doing.
Assuming this does hit the magical $3000 for 7 kWh of storage installed price point I can see it being installed all over. At that point its not a 10+ year proposition to get your money back but more like 5. Heck I would like to have one as my solar system currently exports 2/3's of the power it produces and I would love to have a battery system.
There'll eventually be a correction as storage ramps up (and this makes the payback calculations unreliable). Either connection fees will make up a significantly higher percentage of a bill, or owners of the systems will need to pay for power like commercial properties do with dynamic pricing.
So I'd mostly get a "terrible reporting" vibe from the article. Of course the company will say great things about its very promising technology. It's up to the reporter to not publish the press release.