Wikipedia rejected an entry on Strickland in May because she wasnt famous enough
qz.com
qz.com
To quote Paul Graham on the subject, Deletionists are "constrained by print-era thinking." There is no harm in allowing a large number of articles that people don't frequently read, and being quick to delete articles does have harmful side effects, as evidenced by this case.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bert_(Sesame_Street) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernie_(Sesame_Street) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bert_and_Ernie
I'm fairly passionate about disproportional representation of women scientists. (E.g., Leavitt, Burnell.) In the (more distant) past I've initiated or added to several WP articles about women scientists.
Sometimes editors may be too quick to 'pull the trigger' on stuff ... there are lots of 'unnotable personages' attempts. IMO, in this case (haven't scrutinized it closely) it looks like they tried to be fair in encouraging more 'proof', according to the established standards.
Side note: WP is, if anything, overly protective of orthodox scientific viewpoints. Maybe that colored the thinking here, who knows. But it's up to the submitting editor to make notability clear.
Gérard Mourou, while significantly less famous than Ashkin, has still been the recipient of many awards in the field of optics prior to his Nobel win[2], had previous discoveries to his name, and was the head of some labs and organizations.
Prior to the Nobel award, Donna Strickland was an associate professor. The three were definitely not equal when it came to notability.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_tweezers [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=G%C3%A9rard_Mouro...
So obviously the thing about her being an associate professor says more about her contributions than getting a Nobel Prize.
If you're going to try to explain away a Nobel Prize, you need to look for a new hobby. But I guess fundamentalist beliefs are resistant to evidence...
story checks out; nothing to see here! :^)
edit re downvotes: (not to speak for parent and OP, but) i don't think the claim here is that the kibosh-putting-on of her wikipedia page was done with malicious intent, but simply that bias may have played a role in that decision. and since it was demonstrated pretty damn unambiguously to have been mistaken in this case-- the bar for Nobel Prizes is just a teensy bit above the bar for having a Wikipedia page-- perhaps, as with all mistakes, it is something to learn from and bear in mind in the future. methinks he* doth protest too much?
* about as apt an application of the phrase as you're ever likely to see heh
You say that the decision was "mistaken" as though Wikipedia and the Nobel committee pass judgements of the same nature. But the function of Wikipedia's editors is not to judge whether her scientific work constitutes an "outstanding contribution for humanity" (for which they are evidently ill-equipped), nor is it to judge whether there exist sources which would confer some level of notability on her. It is only to judge whether the particular sources presented confer some level of notability. Looking at the rejected article, the only references are to a paper she published and two biographies on the websites of organizations she belongs to. There is no evidence that "the person's research has had a significant impact in their scholarly discipline, broadly construed, as demonstrated by independent reliable sources" (from "Notability (academics)").
Anyway, I don't see why an encyclopedia should presage notability in the first place. It works the other way around. Now that she has been awarded the Nobel and her impact is beyond all contention "demonstrated by independent reliable sources", she gets a Wikipedia article. That's how it's supposed to work isn't it?