And really, the only way to make it work is if they also get rid of most of the padding. Because even with a rugby form tackle , if you smack into a full padded up football player, that's going to cause some trauma.
And really, the only way to make it work is if they also get rid of most of the padding. Because even with a rugby form tackle , if you smack into a full padded up football player, that's going to cause some trauma.
It might not be a sport at that point, but it would be an interesting spectacle.
However there are other significant differences between (union) rugby and American football which make removing protection dubious. There is no blocking in rugby so only the ball carrier faces being hit and is almost always aware the hit is coming. Also a man on the ground must release hold of the ball so there is no need to go all out to force a fumble.
That's simply not true. When you're taught to tackle, it's always from the point of view of someone running in to you. In fact, I remember "classic"-style tackling from behind being actively discouraged, as no-one wants a mouth full of fast-kicking studs.