Because we've seen studies on what torture does to people and how most people respond to torture. Once a person breaks, they try their best to appease their torturer. An adversary rubber hosing isn't just going to stop when they login and dont get what they want.
In some rather narrow cases it might help avoid random searches from a non-malicious threat. (e.g., border guard just proving a point for whatever reason)
If there is a purpose to recover something from your machine, an invested adversary that is willing to rubber hose is going to keep going. And the numbers seem to show that most people will not have the will and calm to use their duress password when they've been tortured into logging in.