Lampert came in and started running the financial engineering playbook, most crucially the various spinoffs, of which the most important one was the spinoff of Seritage, which is the embodiment of the "RE asset value backstop" strategy. What Seritage does is to partner with the mall landlords (operators like Simon Property Group) to redevelop the former Sears footprint into something more in line with current market preferences (think subdividing into Dave & Buster's, Pandora, etc.) and re-rent the space at a big markup. This is the shell that holds the pea.
None of this benefits from the decline of Sears' core retail operations. Plan A was always to return Sears to profitability, which would have made a killing for ESL. He has struggled mightily to do so, and failed just as mightily. A large amount of effort, capital, brain damage, and reputational has been incurred without a commensurate reward.
But again, Lampert's a very sharp guy; downside protection is in place. Besides the spinoffs (which ring-fenced a bunch of capital), he's migrated a bunch of ESL's investment up the ladder to a creditor position, including big holdings of "fulcrum" securities (unsecured bonds) that will give him a big voice in BK.
A+ for financial engineering; F for business ops. Overall grade: C-.
Not a zero-sum conspiracy working as designed, just desperate wriggling off the hook of a failing workout. Turns out you can't cost-cut Sears to profitability, and competing with Amazon is harder than one might think (?)