I'm not convinced it's worth regulating their hours/locations, but I do sympathize a bit with the brutal economics of restaurants.
Of course they should. There is no assurances or guarantees that any business venture is going to be successful.
If you're running a mexican restaurant that goes out of business because of a taco truck, the answer isn't to outlaw taco trucks, it's to make your own restaurant better.
If you can't change your restaurant and you go out of business isn't it your fault for not adapting to customer tastes and preferences, not the taco trucks fault because it was able to satiate customer needs?
1. Get a few food trucks and park them in front of all potential competitor restaurants. Sell subsidized food.
2. Wait till these restaurants close because they can't compete with the subsidy.
3. Start their own restaurant selling really bad food at expensive prices.
4. Profit.
This is the same kind of strategy that tech giants often follow to push startups out of business. Obviously, my example strategy is extreme (and possibly illegal), but food trucks can easily drive good restaurants out of business resulting in a worse culinary scene in the city. The purpose of the regulation being discussed here is to eliminate such bad forms of competition that result in worse outcomes in the long term.
And yet I don't see anyone out there arguing in favor of laws banning copycat restaurants.
If I can run a food truck and sell food at a lower cost to people who have to stand outside while they eat, and they prefer that over the experience you provide in your restaurant, the customer is not wrong. Good restaurants, by definition do not go out of business.
This requires a substantial investment. It is in no way comparable.
If there is an established profitable business case, financing will be widely and easily available.
6. Now whenever there is an overpriced restaurant, I get delicious, below-cost food from the upstart food trucks.
---- OR ---
5. A new competitor, seeing the overpriced food, sees a profit opportunity and tries to execute the same strategy.
6. The same business from step (1), again does me a favor by providing me delicious food below my expected price.
What is so special about your hypothetical rich person that they become immune to competition or threat of competition upon reaching step 4?
An economy is a complex dynamic system. More importantly, it is continuous. We can certainly analyze fixed time periods and draw conclusions from these, but any conclusion must be drawn in the full understanding that there is a before and an after.
TL;DR Competition doesn't go away because one person did it well, once. Threat of competition can be as effective as actual competition.
People's preferences are not wrong! If people no longer want to give patronage to any kind of establishment that establishment is not entitled to continued business.
Under what circumstances should a restaurant go out of business if not these in your opinion?
The long term equilibrium will be that places to eat that attract people's business will continue to flourish.
The critical thing is that threat of competition is as effective as competition when there are low barriers to entry.
"Undercut and then raise prices" is not a terribly creative strategy - no offense, but you are not the first to come up with it, nor will you be the last. Since it is an obvious strategy, it is always a hanging threat to any restaurant or food truck proprietor. Artificially high prices are not a stable long term equilibrium.
If you are so certain that there is a neglected middle in the restaurant market, then open a restaurant and serve medium-quality food at prices a bit higher than medium-quality prices. It seems to me that if the world you posit that we live in exists, that there should be huge profit opportunity in such a market.
Anecdotally, in my travels everywhere I have been has multiple food options. This spans from small towns of a few thousand to large cities. These options tend to span a price range that is reasonable based on income demographics of the locations they are in.
You could fill in the blank after 'by' and there will be people who turn up at planning meetings or city council meetings to deliver spittle flecked rants about how it'll be the death of the city.
A. A clever way of effectively outlawing something without saying as much (because the legislator understands the implications but has cover as they are "merely keeping them out of residential neighborhoods")
B. The unintended consequences of a legislator not understanding the ramifications of their own [well intentioned?] proposal
Noise, smell, litter, crowds, extra traffic, taking up space from people who wanted to use the park, fumes from generators or burners... lots of reasons.
> instead of hopping in a car and driving 10 minutes to apple/chilis/etc
I mean these aren’t really the only two options are they, come on.
Our Planner also clarified that food trucks are still bound by nuisance ordinances, e.g. for noise and fumes. Granted, claiming a fume nuisance is somewhat difficult, but we already do have laws for residential areas covering things like that. Planning Commission was also concerned about noise and exhaust from things like generators, which could very well happen in your neighbor's yard during a football game.
There's also the use argument. Food trucks are a commercial use, and operating them in a residential zone then suggests that there's a certain commercial use in a zone that, for better or worse, isn't supposed to have that use (as I understand it). As much as we'd like more mixed use, that sort of thing might not work for now. The City also acknowledged that when you mix uses like that, especially in a residential area, it can be contentious for neighbors.
All in all, I imagine they'll leave in the restriction about residential zones, which I think is fine for now. Right now, food trucks aren't specifically legal anywhere in the city, so this ordinance would be a great first step, even if we have to take some more steps later.
Maybe get a few of the truck owners to band together and ask Ann Arbor to try out something like that.
I can think of multiple concrete locations where this would work great without causing a nuisance.
Of course, I don't doubt that there are also more dense and/or differently configured suburbs where this wouldn't work as well.
> I mean these aren’t really the only two options are they, come on.
In many places those are the two options that a) aren't fast food or pizza, b) are family-friendly, and c) within 10 minutes of a large number of houses. Especially in parts of the country that drink more heavily, it's hard to find restaurants that satisfy (b)... tons of restaurants have a very bar-y atmosphere for most of the night.
I mean, feel free to disagree. But... from personal experience, yes, these places exist.
I expect in Ann Arbor that some of the motivation is street parking, of which there is not nearly enough in areas with student houses. And then additionally the disruption of traffic on the narrow residential streets.
The parcels that can have food trucks are near restaurants, so I think they aren't the issue.
Food trucks bypass a lot of this overhead, and it isn't fair to the restaurants. A case of food poisoning can affect a large number of people as well. Lost wages, hospital visits, etc.