The tech giants, the US and the Chinese spy chips that never were; or were they?
theguardian.com
theguardian.com
Yep, that is very likely for 3 sources, but they (assertedly) had 17.
It is really hard to believe to the story, still, besides the journalists/authors there are editors and I cannot believe that - given the relevance of this story - it was not double/triple checked and approved for publishing only after a throroughful review.
Bloomberg says a spy chip was discovered and Apple and Amazon worked with the government to investigate. Apple and Amazon both deny the story is correct.
It links to the Cambridge university security team blog and they say Bloomberg's claim passes the sniff test.
https://www.lightbluetouchpaper.org/2018/10/05/making-sense-...
So whether that's new information or not depends on how much time you waste on HN ;)
Let's make multiple very serious and not reasonable assumptions and jump to the end: a compromised bmc on the network.
It is still non-trivial to get anything accomplished. Either you pass traffic through the likely sinkholed DNS (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenDNS) or make hard coded calls likely to be flagged by ips/ids. Even if you don't get caught immediately, the number of firewalls with access rules to wan to lan traffic back to your ilo/idrac has got to be effectively 0. Even if the access rules are in place, I'd bet Nat isn't - even reverse ssh tunnels require Nat. There are file integrity solutions to check for OS compromises ( https://www.tripwire.com/solutions/file-integrity-and-change...)
The idea that these were shipped randomly globally to Enterprise environments and no one ever figured it out is basically impossible. Maybe there is some grey area and the CTOs and CISOs just never got told what the Frontline admins didn't think was a big deal.
Something else is going on. Maybe this is FUD with China in the title to fuel some political economic maneuvering. Maybe everything about the attack is real except Russia did it to hurt China.
If this story turns out to be wrong, and it also wasn't fraud, it feels wildly unfair for a company to have half evaporated overnight.
Dangerous topic so I'll say that I'm not suggesting limits on journalism or freedom of speech.
A historic example of this is the recording devices we used for Operation Ivy Bells. There was no hiding who the recording devices belonged to because we spray painted "Property of the US Government" on them. Or the Iran nuclear manufacturing tampering that was pulled off for years. Everyone knows who did it because who else could have done it?
Regarding 'scale' - that's not all that important either. If you have someone at SMCI that can get shipping orders then you can easily figure out roughly what batches you need to tamper with in order to make sure your parts end up where they need to go. And it's worth it, even in a small scale, on the hopes of not getting found. No one comes up with one idea of compromising a target and then never waivers from it. You try them all until one works.
True or not, what matters is that the seeds of distrust has been sowed. It's billions of $ lost for Supermicro shareholders, and potentially distrust of China.
And ultimately, why risk confusing people just to make the article prettier? That media outlets do this is one of the many reasons proving that they don't really care about informing their audience.
However, the across-the-board blanket denials seem suspect. Of course you'd deny that you gave a 3 letter agency access to your hardware.
Someone needs to procure one of these tainted boards soon though.
I wish there was a way to filter any headline with a "?".
"The pyramids were built by aliens... or were they?"