Why is it OK to have all our devices, etc. manufactured in China, but it's not OK for Google to offer services there?
Why is it OK to have all our devices, etc. manufactured in China, but it's not OK for Google to offer services there?
This is a great angle. I have no idea, why there is such a huge disparity there, but I have three possible explanations:
1. People do not understand supply chain management (myself included). There is nothing inherently evil about employing people in a foreign country, and not many people are aware that cost of production is lower in China because of (sometimes) horrible working conditions.
2. Google branded itself on "Don't be evil". More or less everyone in western countries would agree that facilitating censorship on a massive scale for the benefit of government officials is "bad".
3. Hypocrisy. Our way of life depends on low wage labour (read: explotiation of the poor) in foreign countries. Our morals follow our wallet.
Clearly the US government has the power to decide the destiny of less powerful countries.
Compared to that, setting up trade agreements with China to ensure human rights, worker safety, environment protection and so on is pretty doable.
In some sense this is true, but manufacturing in China is not just about low wage labour.
The lowest minimum wage in China is 12 RMB/hour. In the US the federal minimum wage is 7.25 USD/hour. Now, 12 RMB ≈ 1.75 USD, but considering purchasing power parity (1), 12 RMB * 3.506 ≈ 6 USD.
The average factory worker wage in China is considerably higher than the minimum wage. In fact it is higher than in some eastern European countries.
Of course the above doesn't tell the whole picture as we haven't looked at for example work and environmental safety. But the lower cost of manufacturing in China can only partly be attributed to lower wages. It also an effect of their industrial network clusters, supply of raw materials, and export subsidies.
Adding to that, manufacturing in China is not just about cost, it is also about the immense scale of their manufacturing capabilities. If you need to churn out half a million iPhone X per day, where else can you get that capability?
(1) Using 2017 value for China from https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-p...
That might not be OK either. People are questioning the wisdom of having "all our devices, etc. manufactured in China."
https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/10/11/if-the-u-s-doesnt-contr...
"The best way to predict the future is to invent it" - Alan Kay
> Why is it OK to have all our devices, etc. manufactured in China, but it's not OK for Google to offer services there?
Because manufacturing our devices there does not directly enable their oppressive practices, such as political censorship. But offering services there does, since China demands that all such services come with censorship tools built-in, and (per this guy's Twitter), actually wants the companies to take down content on demand.
TL;DR: it's the difference between doing business with a known criminal, and assisting them in commission of their crimes.
So, it's OK to give them trillions of dollars in business because we benefit even though they're going to use those trillions to further their agenda? Directly or indirectly, the results are the same.