Hacker News Reader

I'm not sure if this is a puff piece or an ad disguised as an article, but it is quite fluffy.

A more apt title would have been 'Chuchu TV is pretty great, but could it be greater?'

That's a bit unfair, but you're right that "Raised by YouTube" is not a good title for this profile. We've changed the title to use more representative language from the article.

Weren't your criteria 'not misleading or clickbait'? This doesn't seem to be either. 'Good' opens an even bigger can of worms of title bickering.

The title was misleading. The article is a company profile.

It's a 7k-word piece in the print edition of the Atlantic. You've made the case yourself that titles don't have to be trivially revealing - presumably because 'intellectual curiosity' necessarily involves some actual curiosity.

'Raised on Youtube' might be imperfect on some parameter or another but it's not 'misleading' any more than, I dunno, 'The Power Broker' is a misleading title of a biography. The title it's been replaced with is literalist butchery.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com