Ask HNers & PG: Attention paid to feature requests page?
It was created (by PG) three and a half years ago, and you can read the 100s of comments (sorry, too lazy to work out how many) at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=363 - it's also linked to in the site footer.
There's a lot of fringe requests there that I suspect if entered major discussion wouldn't reach any consensus, but some of them seem fairly safe bets for splitting HNers between "I would like this feature" and "I wouldn't mind this feature".
A few examples I selected (either for popularity of votes on that page, or for the fact that I can't see how anyone could argue against them...) are:
84 points, 313 days ago - Subdomains should be shown on submissions: key examples being Google (sites.google.com, code.google.com, etc.), user-content sites such as Posterous/Tumblr/GitHub (a blog can be at *user*.github.com), and sites such as NYTimes (where blogs.nytimes.com is different to www.)
90 points, 837 days ago - Remove up-vote buttons from the main page for unvisited links, to enforce a vote-after-read policy, and remove title baiting.
43 points, 1051 days ago - Allow users to undo up/down votes in the case of a misclick - maybe just highlight the up/down arrow that has been clicked on, rather than removing the buttons?
5 points, 930 days ago - Allow users to delete their own account
4 points, 369 days ago - Password recovery
Aside from wondering whether the above ideas might get implemented, a wider question is: would it be worth going through that entire topic, chosing between implementation or rejection for each idea, then wiping the slate clean and starting fresh? It would make it much easier to browse other people's ideas (that thread is very long, takes a hell of a time to really read through everything), and hopefully encourage more debate on each new idea.n.b. I'm not trying to push for the selection of suggestions I copied above, they're just examples that I feel could be good changes. More trying to raise interest in the topic.
Thoughts?