There is, in fact, a lot of internal outrage. I wouldn't call this cherry picking.
(Source: I work there)
(Source: I work there)
Now, it's entirely possible 60% of the employees actually are outraged, but we have no way of knowing outside a survey.
Hence the NYT is cherry-picking an opinion based on anecdotal data (that just so happens to positively reflect on their earlier coverage), when it's also entirely possible that 80% of Googlers don't really care.
The headline and story imply the NYT has a firm handle on how the bulk of 85,000 people think, which is not the case.
https://www.surveysystem.com/sscalc.htm
"80% of Googlers don't really care" would be an extreme outlier, statistically.