>> Such protection should be effectively guaranteed through the introduction, in Union law, of rights related to copyright for the reproduction and making available to the public of press publications in respect of digital uses in order to obtain fair and proportionate remuneration for such uses.
Which makes some sense. If you have a digital version that needs to still give you money but them:
>> In addition, the listing in a search engine should not be considered as fair and proportionate remuneration.
Says you will have to pay in a different from just driving traffic to those ppl.
Now if I’m a Creative Commons news outlet there is no way for me to waive that extra payment. The law states that just listing me somewhere is not enough and I need to be paid in a different way. I may not want that but the law INSISTS that I get paid in a different way.
Does this make it more clear?
I'm not saying the recital 32 is great, and clear and amazing. It's not, but it doesn't mean much until it gets into a draft regulation/directive, gets challenged in court, etc.
"In addition, the listing in a search engine should not be considered as fair and proportionate remuneration."
seems to be specifically targeted at search engines. I'm not sure how this is about a "link tax" more than it is about a "search engine tax". I'm fairly certain we will still be able to share our links on Facebook and Twitter, the embedded excerpts might be in jeopardy though.
>> The Directive is extremely vague on what defines a "link" or a "news story" and implies that an "excerpt" consists of more than one single word from a news-story (many URLs contain more than a single word from the headline).
So it is based on the link and also the main point is to force news outlets to get more money for nothing more than a link which drives traffic to them anyways...
Okay maybe the most correct definition should be: “search engine link tax” from this specific excerpt but it is also left very vague. What’s is a search engine. Is github a search engine? Are links to news articles on GitHub issues the same fate as on google?
So then you go back and think of the potential “search engines” out there and it does start to feel more like a “link tax” because most things can be considered a search engine.
//OFFTOPIC: I mean is anything built with full text search a where clause not close to a search engine (in theory)? Lol
The law is supposed to prevent re-publishing of content with minor attribution ala Google News or this type of thing[0] from Boing Boing. The proposed law states specifically that "the act of hyperlinking" is excluded[1] and even says that "insubstantial parts ... (for instance very short excerpts)" would not be against the law[2].
[0] - https://boingboing.net/2018/09/10/at-insane-speeds-moto2-rid... [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_... [2] - http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2018/...