What I imagine happened in your tests is, you didn't compare two different implementations of the same UI, you implemented the form via two different UI's and the users preferred the experience of new one to the old one.
I believe that you compared different UI's because otherwise you wouldn't need user testing: you could just measure the latency and code complexity.
The person you are responding to is saying, for a fixed user interface design, the necessary state management will be the same and your only choice is how to implement it. You say you believe this to be false but it doesn't seem like you are responding to the point.