The problem with education philanthropy
vox.com
vox.com
When I talk to people in the US most of them seem to think that the current systems are hopeless and can't be improved, be it infrastructure, health or education.
Philanthropy can help maybe a little but I think it's more important to improve current systems. You can't just let things for slowly and hope for billionaires to fix them. They won't.
For trades its all about your benefits. its the old-timers that move into teaching. No greybeard wants to hire on at a private school for higher private rates but ultimately lower benefits. A woman for 40 years experience as a plumber will choose lower pay at the city college for better health, retirement, and vacation packages.
The state also wins big again at trade colleges because many of the instructors have worked 40 years in the largest fleets: city bus or EMS/Police motor pool. These people are legends in their field and the city goes to great lengths to keep them around. Private colleges might get the occasional lead mechanic from Nascar or a pro-racing circuit endorsement, but she hasnt held a wrench to a normal engine in more than a decade.
lastly its about content. private schools polls industry to see what they want, and if industry is short on good (cheap) oil change monkeys then thats most of what youll learn. Old-timers know you'll need more than an oil pan to bring home a paycheck. Theyll teach you things to make you faster, safer, and better at all the work you need to do.
Yes, Education is undoubtedly an important problem to solve and the "return on investment" to society is huge, but it's one which already receives significant investment/budget and throwing more money at the problem is often counterproductive.
While the article does not mention Finland, I feel it should. Finland has considerably better education standards than (any state in the) USA by all measures on PISA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programme_for_International_St...
In 2014, the U.S. spent an average of $12,157 per student on elementary and secondary education. see: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/020915/what-country... Finland's education budget is €2,100 per capita. ($2,400 USD i.e. less than 20% of the spending!) Spending less money leads to a much better outcome for students. No billionaires required. Just take the profit out of education.
Tuition fees are _strictly prohibited by law in Finland. Which means everyone receives the same standard of education regardless of their parents/family's financial situation. see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Finland
Why Finland has the Best Education (Michael Moore Doc): https://youtu.be/XQ_agxK6fLs Summary: No homework! All schools are the same standard.
Top 10 Reasons Finland has the World’s Best School System: https://youtu.be/zmG4smezeME
Further reading: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/why-are-finlands-s...
US spending per pupil is $12,300
Finland spending per pupil is $9,800
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/pdf/coe_cmd.pdf
If you want to look at per capita spending, the article says the US spends about 668 billion, divided by a population of 321 million, you get about $2080 per capita.
So if you're calculating it that way, the US actually spends _less_ per capita than Finland.
> So if you're calculating it that way, the US actually spends _less_ per capita than Finland.
Nobody is calculating it that way: the US does not have 321 million schoolchildren.
The top-level poster did, in a (hopefully unintentionally) grossly misleading apples-to-oranges comparison:
> U.S. spent an average of $12,157 per student [...] Finland's education budget is €2,100 per capita [...] less than 20% of the spending!
I also think US system is fundamentally flawed because of government established monopoly. This prevents other players to come in and make improvements. Even worse, students in US is tied to a school based on house a parent can afford. Why can't a parent take education allowance from government and go to any school they prefer? This would allow competition, private entities, market economy and most importantly fast evolution by innovating on other factors.