Microsoft regularly shared data of India bank customers with US intelligence
scroll.in
scroll.in
As long as market is OPEN to all, there is no harm introducing "Financial data on local servers only" regulations.
[1]https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/startups/news...
1. Scroll anonymously reposted a poorly-written article from DNA. (First link in first sentence)
2. Look at the facts quoted in the article. "Banks know that Microsoft MIGHT be sharing". (emphasis mine) What does the title say? It doesn't say what the banks say. Banks know that it COULD happen under some circumstances. The article title omits any sense of uncertainty and says it definitely already has happened. Those are different.
3. The article quotes a number of 3,036 requests for "Indian customers in the US" which means NOT PEOPLE IN INDIA. And certainly not customers of RBI in India (which the article would have you believe). Indian nationals living in the US have a different expectation with respect to US law enforcement.
4. Microsoft has issued a strong and clear rebuttal.https://news.microsoft.com/en-in/setting-the-record-straight...
This was wild conjecture, un-sourced anonymous writing, and it was poorly fact-checked. It looks like the author saw a single document that they didn't understand. Then they wrote a bunch of conspiracy theory bogey-man nonsense that has nothing to do with the document they saw.
Then all businesses are forbidden to use foreign software due to possible back doors.
Other countries with sane laws can also group together to scale.
Think banking secrecy, but for cloud data.
Yes, it is possible, easily is not a word I would use though.
>> The end goal is data on their citizens are more easily obtainable by local government.
I think this is a sensible requirement, don't you think? What makes the U.S. gov more eligible than the local gov to access their citizens data? It's not only a national security issue, it's a local police issue as well(i.e. finding criminals based on their digital fingerprints).
The current situation is quite ridiculous if you think about it. You can't have global services without a global "police". As we don't have a global police(yet) local gov try to make these global companies to store data locally.
Siginicant data collected on individuals across the world via social media are held with US companies that must follow the processes put in place to provide Law Enforcement with data regardless of the citizenship of the person, when someone commits a crime in one jurisdiction, that local law enforcement has the right to collect from the business, data needed to support their case.
The problem is when Bob from country X commits a crime "social media business" may have relevant information on, how cooperative will the US company be in helping country X? Especially if country x is politically unpopular at the moment.
Require local subsidiaries follow data protection and retention that adheres to local law. Everything gets much easier.
Another issue, "social media business" has a tone of information on citizens of country X, now the citizens of country X are vulnerable to manipulation which could disrupt the stability of country X. What do they do?
Right now when I do risk analysis, I consider any american service, whether they have servers in Europe or not as high risk. We are currently moving our elasticSearch to cloud and one requirment we have focused on is nulling out the personal data before it even enters the AWS network.
If this would have happened to a developed country, I am guess it would have been a huge uproar by now.
"...unidentified company spokesperson."
If this was a true statement, why wouldn't anyone at Microsoft be willing to hang their name on it?
Also of note, the Bank of India said they received no requests in 2016 or 2017 from Microsoft but the first paragraph notes the ~4000 requests were made from 2014-2016.
> The RBI said Microsoft agreed to disclose information on 3,036 occasions between 2014 and 2016 in response to more than 4,000 government requests or legal demand requests for data of Indian customers in the US.
> according to Microsoft, it had received “zero demands from the US law enforcement for commercial enterprise content located outside the United States” in 2016 and 2017.
In the first sentence, I think the requests were from the RBI and not US intelligence.
They can just keep a copy in both places, allowing them to simultaneously "have zero requests for content outside the US" and "share data of India bank customers".
Then there's the simple fact that it doesn't scale to copy everybody's data to the US. When you're as big as one of these major cloud providers, that's just simply not possible.