>
The tech required for search and rescue is the same tech required for search and destroy.Haha, no, no it's not. (I'm very active in SAR -- headed out to a large search this weekend, even.)
We've had "search and destroy" for a decade now, but SAR still doesn't have effective use of drones. Quadcopters can navigate tricky terrain close enough to the ground to see a sufficient amount of detail, but they only get about 25 minutes of flight time.
Fixed-wing drones can get much better flight time, but we can't put them anywhere near close enough to the ground to see the average missing person.
Typically the next thing people suggest is IR. Yeah, IR's great, there's just one problem: there are a lot of IR sources on the ground, even in the wilderness, and people with clothing on aren't that great a source of IR by comparison. At a recent multi-agency training event, I reviewed footage from a repurposed Reaper drone flown by the national guard after the southern California mudslides. Making out the difference between a person on the ground and a streetlamp was impossible.
The only documented drone find I've heard of so far was a person sitting in an orchard. Probably there have been others, but the point is: SAR is a wildly different situation than people imagine.
There was just a study done by DJI and European agencies that found that drones were of negligible benefit in the missing person scenarios they tried: https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2018/october/01...
Helicopters and civil air patrol are superior to drones in almost every way. I've hung out the side of a UH-60 and a couple of Lakotas during exercises looking for brightly colored objects on the ground. At around 100 feet above ground level our success rate was around 60%.
Heck, we had a missing small aircraft, in the snow, a year and a half ago. There were hundreds of searchers on the ground, multiple CAP and helo overhead. Guess who found it? Some folks on snowmobiles a few weeks later.
We use a number called "POD" -- Probability of Detection -- in our reports after every assignment. It's an ass-pull guesstimate at what our odds were of locating a responsive subject, an unresponsive subject, or a clue during the assignment. High POD for a close grid search pattern on the ground in light forest for an unresponsive subject is about 70%. Average POD for an unresponsive subject by a fleet of quadcopters in the same environment would be like 5%. To effectively rule the area out, any decent search manager would deploy a ground team anyway.
So, in the first place, this MIT experiment -- while very cool -- still suffers from a lot of the same issues that this technology has in a SAR context. And in the second place, shooting down efforts to develop this technology for civilian use is silly because, well, I hate to break it to ya, but we've been killing people with (mostly autonomous) drones for a while now. That horse is already outta the barn.