Has there been any robust evidence that brain images correspond to any real world capability differences?
An AMD and Intel cpu look very different under an xray too, but they run the same software at pretty much the same specs.
I don't understand how someone who would (probably) call themselves progressive can use reheated talking points from 18th century eugenicists without noticing a problem.
[0] Not someone having their frontal lobes cut off.
[1] https://africacheck.org/2015/03/12/analysis-black-brain-whit...
If you take for granted that brain physiology in healthy brains impacts brain capacity then you're a couple of stray neurons away from justifying Jim Crow V 2.0, now with more science.
Hormones aren't any better, back in the 60s and 70s 'negroes' were said to be in heat constantly which is why they needed to be paternalistically protected by the nice Alabama state troopers.
I'm pretty sure the cortical and white matter tract differences also map to different cognitive abilities (regardless of sex/gender, but some of them are more represented in a given sex/gender). As far as the brain is concerned, structure is function.
Also various CPUs may be able to execute the same code, yet their architecture differences will impact their relative performance in both speed and energy efficiency.
--
0. https://academic.oup.com/brain/article/131/12/3132/295849
I should point out that men and women are more similar than different and we can generally "run the same software at pretty much the same specs". But that's a separate discussion - the original article is looking at differences in preferences, not abilities.
This shouldn't be a difficult ask.
The only hard and fast link there is one where they knock off genes in female mice and get them to act more like male mice.
This is specifically not what I asked proof for.
This whole debate smacks of phrenology to me. The last 100 years in philosophy have taught us that any Turing machine can act like any other with at most a quadratic reduction in speed. It is unfortunate that neuroscience is still stuck in a 19th century mode of thinking where we mistake form for function with all the terrible results of the 20th century to show for it.
If the brain isn't a Turing machine and people aren't capable of running any software in their head they so chose we are in a very uncomfortable place where we need to start looking at eugenics seriously again. A place I definitely do not want to be in.
This is a pretty bad example. Although the two CPUs may be compatible, the micro architecture differs substantially, frequently causing Intel processors to excel where AMD struggles and vice versa.
Although the CPUs are capable of the same things, we might say they have different, erm, 'preferences.'
http://ratio.se/app/uploads/2016/09/ls_ideology_insights_gen...
Lots of people seem to like him, but I can't bring myself to watch him speak in person since everything I see just traversing the internet is framed as him "destroying liberals" in some fashion, which just affirms the insufferable idea.
sure, there's a lot of "feminist owned by Peterson's logic" stuff out there, but that's the culture war for you.
Maybe not "doesn't understand", it could just be disregard.
Very simply the book seems uphold a philosophy that ignores that other people might have actual struggles and histories.
I have a couple specific examples I can put up when I'm out of the office.
Better yet, interviews with him and Dave Rubin or Joe Rogan, or his discussions with Sam Harris, are great ways to get a non-combative side of him.
They "steel man" each other, putting up the best form of each other's arguments. The opposite of creating/attacking straw men.
What I did find interesting were his interviews on the "joe rogan experience". There are three of them on youtube, here is the newest one: https://youtu.be/9Xc7DN-noAc
If it's any consolation, I did like the chapter titles, each one was generally a good piece of advice, it was the content and justifications that were the issue.
why would anyone? if it's not a discussion it's a battle of ideologies and someone (them/they) have to win
I did no such thing how dare you
True.
> but that's the only reasonable conclusion based on your statement
False.
In full.
Peterson doesn't publish his ideas in academic outlets. He is avoiding the proper discourse.
And for Peterson in particular, it makes even more sense. He claims academia has been corrupted - particularly the social sciences, like the one in which he is engaged. If you were him, why would you ever write a paper for corrupted academics to denounce you? That's like asking why someone doesn't try to speak at a RNC event and try to convince everyone in the room to switch to the Dem stance on immigration and abortion. It would never happen. Seems to me that Peterson has made rational choices given his set of claims and alleged beliefs. His strategy seems entirely sound as far as I can see. I'd also say that he doesn't shy aware from attending any speaking event or being a guest on any show. He's even said things about how his attendance in potentially adversarial discussions/debates is an important function of the way he does things because there's value in discussing things with people who disagree with him. There's little value, or at least far less, in going on a program that is an echo chamber. I've seen him throw himself into many situations that I would describe as hostile or adversarial. Doesn't seem like he's avoiding any sort of proper discussion and he seems more than willing to defend his statements.
I would be genuinely interested in some details about the alleged misrepresentations you stated. If you are willing to share, I have an open mind and admit to not having studied most of those topics at great length so if Peterson is misrepresenting them, I would love to hear the details. I am particularly interested in how he might be misrepresenting the law, as that is something I do study (although not Canadian law).
He had a successful clinical psychology practice for years. I'm not sure that's possible if your suspicion is true.
Is having mild autism a bad thing? Why?
By itself, stating that someone may be 'mildly autistic' has no bearing on the validity of their ideas.
Also I wasn't arguing his ideas, I was asking if his speaking worth spending the time on after his book was lacklustre.
Edit: For a deeper dive into why I specifically used the term "nonsensical". See this article [1]. I was thinking these exact things while reading his writing.
[1] https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/03/the-intellectual-we-d...
In these politically tumultuous times, you simply cannot separate the two. Nor could you do the same during the political upheaval of the 20th century seeing as though a lot of us have very strong political convictions.
If you pay attention to the guy, he talks about his pondering on whether without the benefit of hindsight bias that we have now, he would have been a happy guard at Auschwitz. It speaks to character; a very personal thing. When you map that on to what's happening today with all the polarization, there are many ways in which answering such questions honestly to yourself makes you a better person whether you're on the right or left of the political divide.