This strikes me as... very inauthentic. I think anyone with even a basic understanding of crypto would do things the other way around.
This strikes me as... very inauthentic. I think anyone with even a basic understanding of crypto would do things the other way around.
Can you explain your reasoning? PGP lacks forward secrecy, a key feature that you'd want and which OTR provides.
The person I was responding to claimed that PGP was the superior choice to OTR, and I wanted to understand why.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-the-Record_Messaging#Nativ...
I feel like this discussion is getting away from the original premise:
> anyone with even a basic understanding of crypto would do things the other way around.
i.e. use PGP instead of OTR. Nobody has yet even attempted explain their reasoning as to why? Bringing up one specific vendor is a deflection, rather than an answer.
> anyone with even a basic understanding of crypto would do things the other way around.
Not least of all because they made no reference to which implementation of PGP they were even calling superior, only the protocol itself.
It's not about the technical features that are theoretically available, it's more about how much you can believe they actually hold in reality.
OTR uses AES-128 w/the Diffie–Hellman key exchange, and SHA-1 hashes to confirm integrity. So in terms of technology it is a pretty well travelled road. And the advantages of OTR over PGP make it worth seriously considering for secure messaging.
As to specific implementations I cannot say, but that's true with both OTR and PGP.
That's exactly the root of the problem. When you say you use pgp, there's a very high chance you're using gnupg from the command line, ie the one that has been reviewed by every security expert who has wanted any bit of recognition. When you say you're using OTR, everything depends on the specific implementation, so there are infinitely more ways your setup can be compromised.
I do agree that from a purely technical point of view OTR is better than PGP (except maybe the need for both parties to be online at the same time, but that's a minor inconvenience when comparing to the additional security OTR provides). But in this case the technical merits are not really important, what is really important is the complete system, and in that view the old, crufty, hard-to-use PGP wins.
Sure, it's true. But that reasoning kinda obviates everything. Some things are easier to use safely than others. Your second paragraph is basically the essence of criticisms against PGP.