I'd dare to call it pretentious: "your code is bad and it's your fault the world is a mess but I, the genius not at fault for and detached from any of this, know how to fix all of it".
I'd dare to call it pretentious: "your code is bad and it's your fault the world is a mess but I, the genius not at fault for and detached from any of this, know how to fix all of it".
Overall it seems quite reasonable except maybe for the tone that was off-putting to many apparently
I think a lot of code is bad, and the world is a mess. But I have no idea about your code, and I'm not sure who is at fault, or even if that's a useful question to ask. I'm certainly no genius, and I definitely don't know how to fix all of it.
I read it as: "We can do better but the current way of doing things looks broken to me. We should start by replacing it with something VERY different."
That's not how any kind of writing works. You aren't allowed to go, "This is what I wrote, but the way this poster wrote it is what I actually mean." The author will always carry some of the responsibility for interpretation via the words and grammar they use. Reader interpretation is not a way to handwave criticism of the writer's tone or the content they share.
Basically, how you choose to read it is a part of the experience, like reading a literature.
Hence I believe that people are projecting while reading it. I know I did.