I always appreciated Fourquares more straight forward Good, OK, bad approach to reviewing.
Tripadvisor has always been best for me, in the UK, but you do have to interpret reviews carefully.
Yelp tends to be worse outside the US so I tend to agree Tripadvisor is relatively better. But in the US, I'll often look at Tripadvisor for B&Bs etc. but I tend to come back to Yelp for restaurants.