Don't large part of some American industries depend on such immigrant labor? I even hear comedians like Bill Maher joke about this all the time saying things like "without illegal immigrants there would be nobody to pick fruit" so it almost seems like an accepted reality of US, at least agriculture industry in border states. Is that no true? I just assumed jokes and lines like that are based on some sort of universally accepted "unofficial" truth, that's what makes them funny.
My mother worked at a produce company most of her life. She said the workers always had paperwork. The company didn't try very hard to verify the authenticity of the paperwork. They would work for two weeks, get their check and be gone, off to work at another field for two weeks.
If an industry requires illegal subsidies to thrive, there is no industry. They should naturally go bankrupt. If a nation decides it is important enough to subsidize (i.e. strategic food stock to feed a populace), then they should do so through funding bills instead of hiding the true cost through the lack of immigration enforcement.
But the farming lobby is powerful.
> They should naturally go bankrupt.
No, they should disinstitute by themselves.
The situation may have arised naturally, and then the government refused to deal with it effectively (actually penalize companies that hire illegal immigrants) because business interests liked the situation.
Illegal immigrants are a commodity, for businesses that use them, for politicians that claim to protect you from them, for the industry that processes them