Amazon deal will disrupt plans for affordable housing on Long Island City sites
politico.com
politico.com
What's worse - a lot of these programs mandate things to private developers, thus raising prices for the market-rate middle class units. Double whammy.
How do I know this? Because I've seen this all happen. Of the 10 or so households who got affordable housing in MA, I know that more than 8 got it because they didn't really qualify but knew how to play the tricks. One of our family friends is actually trying to divorce his wife (just in the papers) so that the wife gets higher preference rating for a certain house they're going for.
This has been my experience with affordable housing as a New Yorker:
1. Units don't necessarily go to those who need them most. A percentage are always set aside for city employees (public data) and when evaluating applications, developers tend to pick the applicants with the highest credit scores and most stable backgrounds. These people tend to be the ones who need the housing the least (source: real estate friend.
It's also not common for recent graduates with low incomes but wealthy parents to get the housing (source: people I know who did this).
2. You're allowed to keep the housing forever, even if your income skyrockets.
3. Affordable housing is often built in the wrong locations. It doesn't make sense to put a $800 / month apartment in a luxury neighborhood where residents can't even afford to buy coffee, but this is often what happens.
4. Continuing the point above, developers usually design affordable units in exactly the same way as luxury market-rate units. This raises costs that the developers must recoup from the market-rate units. Do subsidized renters really need marble countertops?
5. The affordable units built are really just a trickle in a waterfall of all the high-end housing coming to market.
The best solution would be to encourage the building of quality, affordable apartments directly in the neighborhoods where people need them most. Even better, the city should improve transportation infrastructure so that the free market can fix the affordable housing issue on its own.
I also agree with you on the point of public transit in infrastructure. I’m in SF, and not many people who work in the city can afford to live in it. This makes reliable and affordable transit critical as most working class folks are pushed into outlying cities suburbs.
I think the bigger difference is the commitment to effective mass transportation in the whole tri-state area, which is a huge help in mitigating the affordable housing problem.