The "green bits" are pumped into real estate across the US (not to mention Canada, the UK, and Auckland), inflating housing prices and making it harder for housing consumers to acquire property (kudos Vancouver for your foreign buyer tax!). Jobs are not created with these investment dollars.
Warren Buffet warned us of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bGo_NL-eclw (trade imbalances lead to serfdom)
In places that can build more housing, it is done. In places it can't be done, or the local citizens don't want it done, it is not. "Build, baby, build!" is just as ridiculous as "Drill, baby, drill!" [1] We work backwards from those two fundamental truths.
I have a feeling places like SF and NY have already tried this. Considering most of these foreign investors are most interested in these two cities over lets say Nebraska, it's hard to see how NY just needs to "build more supply" is a solution.
> If we had policies that encouraged always building
We have those in Australia, it's called negative gearing. We also have the most expensive houses when compared to average income and our cities have taken your advice and started to build up at rapid paces. Still hasn't worked.
The Aus government is now suggesting we lower our immigration cap from 1% of total pop yearly so maybe that will help.
Isn't it just a strange (legal) tax loophole which enough people take advantage of that it's difficult to get rid of politically?
Also there are other forms of tax besides property tax, so governments don’t need expensive property to fund their services.
Indeed. That was basically post-war US economic policy in a nutshell. The worrying about reducing the trade deficit is a purely political argument. Trump is simply the first person in power to actually believe the nuttery.